HomeMy WebLinkAboutASAB minutes 081606Animal Services Advisory Board (ASAB)
Approved Minutes for August 16, 2006, Meeting
Scheduled for Review and Approval at Next ASAB Meeting
Present ASAB Members: Tracy Carroll, Daniel Textoris, Lisa Smith, Ross Oglesbee, DeWana
Anderson, DVM, Moses Carey, Jr., Pat Sanford, Jean ConneratLevine, James Kramer, Susan
Elmore, DVM, Bonnie Norwood and Kristine Bergstrand, DVM.
Absent ASAB Members: None
Others in Attendance: Animal Services Director Bob Marotto, Animal Shelter Director Joe
Pulcinella, Animal Control Manager Irene Paul and Administrative Assistant Paula Ragan.
Public Speakers in AttendanceAmanda Arrington, Suzanne Roy, Emily Weinstein, Marlene
Hankins and Tom Garner.
Welcome and Opening Comments Chair of the ASAB Committee, Tracy Carroll.
Meeting Agenda: Motion was made by Bonnie Norwood and seconded by Moses Carey, Jr. to
approve the Proposed Agenda dated August16th, 2006. VOTE: Unanimous.
Approval of Meeting Minutes: Motion was made by Ross Oglesbee and seconded by Lisa Smith
to approve the minutes dated June 21, 2006. VOTE: Unanimous.
General Public Each member of the public was ask to introduce themselves and requested to
sign up on the sign up sheets for any items they would like to speak on, rather on the agenda or
not on the agenda. No public comments were made at this time on items not on the agenda.
Unfinished Business—
Foster Program Review: Ms. Oglesbee and Mr. Pulcinella have reviewed and made some
revisions to the foster program documents per the request of Board Members since the last ASAB
meeting. As a result of discussion at the Board meeting, a number of other specific editorial
changes will be made to prior review and approval. Also, it was requested that a monthly status
report on the foster program be made to the ASAB, and additionally that there be a sixmonth
report to determine the overall progress of the program.
The Board agreed that the committee would identify specific concerns and make all the necessary
changes and bring the Foster Program working documents back to the Board in to final format
for adoption at the next ASAB meeting.
New Business Chair Carroll provided an update on ASAB renewals (Ross Ogelsbee) and new
appointments (Dr. Susan Elmore) as well as expected vacancies (position held by Lisa Smith).
Chair Carroll indicated that the letter distributed to Board members by an employee of the
Animal Services Department would not be discussed but that it would instead be forwarded to the
ASAB Approved Minutes—
August 16 th , 2006, Meeting
Page 2
Personnel Department. She and Mr. Marotto further indicated that any operational concerns
raised in the letter would be identified by Mr. Marotto so that these issues could be considered in
an appropriate way.
Review of Select Department Updates: Robert Marotto, Director, Animal Services Department
presented select department updates based upon an August 16 th , 2006, memorandum
summarizing recent activities and accomplishments in the Animal Control and Animal Shelter
Divisions of the Animal Services Department.
Animal Services Facility Project: Information about the existing shelter and shelter site was
presented including that the site lease was expected to be extended through the latter part of 2009
and that required environmental remediation would not require the closure of the shelter. The
remediation itself is expected to occur over a period of several months in the winter of 2007/2008
and it will necessitate alternative access to and parking for the shelter.
A number of proposals from teams including a local and a nationally known architect
specializing in animal shelter design have been received, and they will be reviewed by staff and
County Commissioners over the next several weeks. The Board of County Commissioners
(BOCC) will be appointing a Design Committee concurrent with the selection of the Architect.
Some of the members for this committee will be coming from the community at large and that
there should be two representatives from the ASAB. Motion was made by Tracy Carroll and
seconded by Daniel Textoris to nominate Dr. Susan Elmore and Pat Sanford for the Design
Committee for the new Animal Shelter.VOTE: Unanimous
Citizen Concerns: Tracy Carroll and Bob Marotto spoke on the manner in which citizen
concerns should be received, acknowledged, reviewed and processed regarding all operations
and activities conducted under the auspices of the Animal Services Department. Included in the
ASAB packet is a memorandum dated August 8 th , 2006 from Bob Marotto listing some of the
specific citizen concerns that have recently been brought to his attention.
It was recommended in addition to the public comment section offered during ASAB meetings that
some type of defined process should be put in place to receive, respond and include citizens
concerns and that concerns and complaints will be integrated into the ASAB Agenda. Motion
was made by Ross Oglesbee and seconded by Jim Kramer that there will be drafted a complaint
process and procedure in a timely manner. VOTE: Unanimous.
Tethering: Bob Marotto gave a reprise of prior ASAB discussions regarding tethering and the
current provisions and regulations that are in place with Orange County. He noted that Irene
Paul, Animal Control Manager has worked on an instrument that can and should be used by
Animal Control Officers in conduct of inspections regarding tethering. He also noted that there
are expressions of deep community concerns about tethering in Orange County as well as
Durham County that have brought the issue to the attention of the ASAB and resulted in other
developments such as the adoption of a resolution by Durham’s InterNeighborhood Council.
The following citizens spoke and gave their views on prohibiting or limiting tethering in Orange
County and provided various types of related handouts: Amanda Arrington, Suzanne Roy, Emily
Weinstein, and Marlene Hankins. Among other things, specific comments addressed issues of
ASAB Approved Minutes
August 16, 2006Meeting
Page 3
crime associated with chained dogs; children attacked by chained dog and the overall
aggressiveness of chained dogs; and experiences with embedded chains or collars in the necks of
dogs and chained dogs not being vaccinated or spay/neutered.
Tom Garner spoke on his views for tethering. He did a comparison of the space available to a
dog that stays in a 10 foot by ten foot pen versus a dog with a ten foot tether. He indicated that
tethering was more secure, provided dogs with more space, resulted in fewer injuries, and that
tethered dogs have a greater sense of freedom.
Motion was made by Pat Sanford and seconded by Moses Carey, Jr. to select Jean Connerat
Levine, Dr. Kristine Bergstrand, Bob Marotto and Irene Paul to create a Tethering Committee
charged with gathering and organizing pertinent information and identifying avenues of public
input and comment on any possible recommendations. The motion also indicated that the
Tethering Committee includes a crosssection of community members of representatives relative
to the issue of tethering. VOTE: Unanimous.
Motion was made by Jean ConneratLevine and seconded by Jim Kramer to have an
ASAB Meeting on September 20 th , 2006. VOTE: Unanimous.
Motion was made by Pat Sanford and seconded by Moses Carey, Jr. to adjourn meeting at 8:45
p.m. Vote: Unanimous.
Next ASAB Meeting: Wednesday, September 20, 2006 at 6:30 p.m. at Southern Human Services
Center Room A&B Homestead Road, Chapel Hill