HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda - 04-24-1989 AIRPORT WORK SESSION
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
APRIL 24, 1989 6:30 P.M.
•
SUPERIOR COURTROOM
A. CALL THE MEETING TO ORDER
B. OUTLINE THE PROCESS THAT WILL BE FOLLOWED FOR THIS WORK
SESSION:
1. TOM MCDOWELL, MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT WITH MCDEVCO
WILL GIVE AN ACCOUNTING OF THE EVENTS THAT HAVE LED
UP TO THIS POINT.
2. THE ECONOMIC WORTH COMPONENT WILL BE DISCUSSED.
3. THE CRITERIA FOR THE SITES AND HOW THEY HAVE BEEN
APPLIED TO THE 20 POTENTIAL SITES WILL BE GIVEN.
THE SIX SITES WILL BE ANNOUNCED. HORACE WILLIAMS IS
THE SEVENTH SITE.
DURING THE PRESENTATION, THE BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
WILL BE ASKING QUESTIONS WHICH MAY ANSWER SOME OF
YOUR CONCERNS.
4. AT THE END OF THE PRESENTATION THERE WILL BE A TEN
MINUTE RECESS. DURING THIS TEN MINUTE RECESS,
THE VARIOUS GROUPS PRESENT SHOULD SELECT A
SPOKESPERSON TO PRESENT QUESTIONS THEY MAY HAVE.
THE QUESTION AND ANSWER SESSION WILL BE LIMITED TO
THIRTY MINUTES.
PLEASE IF YOU ARE THE. REPRESENTATIVE FROM YOUR
GROUP, COME FORWARD DURING THIS TEN MINUTE RECESS
AND COMPLETE THE "REQUEST TO SPEAK FORM" AND RETURN
THIS FORM TO THE CLERK. WE WILL TAKE AS MANY
QUESTIONS AS WE HAVE TIME.
5. AT THE END OF THE QUESTION AND ANSWER SESSION,
THE PROPOSED LEGISLATION FOR THE IMPACT TAX WILL BE
CONSIDERED. (THIS ITEM WAS CONTINUED FROM THE APRIL
18TH B/C MEETING) .
7. BEFORE WE START WITH THE PRESENTATION, I WOULD LIKE
TO READ THE PUBLIC CHARGE.
--;
ORANGE COUNTY
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
ACTION AGENDA ITEM ABSTRACT 016
Meeting Date: January 20. 1987
Action Agenda
Item #
SUBJECT: AIRPORTS TASK FORCE - CHARGE
***************************************************************************
DEPARTMENT: COUNTY MANAGER PUBLIC HEARING: Yes_X_No
***************************************************************************
ATTACHMENTS: CONTACT: Manager' s Office
X501
TELEPHONE NUMBERS:
Hillsborough 732-8181
Chapel Hill 967-9251
Durham 688-7331
Mebane 227-2031
***************************************************************************
PURPOSE: To consider for approval a charge to the Airports
Task Force for preparing a report on issues
associated with the relocation of Horace Williams
Airport in Chapel Hill.
NEED: Horace Williams Airport is located in the northern
portion of Chapel Hill on N.C.Highway 86. The
airport has a basic and general utility
classification, serving general aviation needs as
well as the UNC Medical School. the University of
North Carolina. the N.C. Memorial Hospital and
local businesses.
Residential development over the past two decades.
including the construction of two schools. Guy B.
Phillips Junior High and Estes Hill Elementary. has
encroached upon the airport. Two other schools -
Seawell Elementary and Chapel Hill High School -
are also nearby. Residents and school officials
have complained about noise associated with airport
operations and the threat to the safety of student.
The Chair of the Board of Commissioners desires to
appoint a Task Force for the purpose of finding
another site for the airport. Advertisements have
been placed in newspapers to attract persons
interested in serving on the Task Force. The Task
Force would include UNC and N.C. Memorial Hospital
representatives as well as Town and County
residents and officials.
IMPACT: Approval of a charge to the Task Force would enable
. , • the group to focus immediately on issues related to
07brelocating Horace Williams Airport and reduce the
length of time required to produce a report to the
Board of Commissioners.
RECOMMENDATION: Approve a charge to the Task Force to include
the following tasks:
1. Identify advantages. disadvantages and barriers
to the relocation of Horace Williams Airport.
2. Solicit early public comment on the subject
of possible relocation to clarify issues and
identify special interests.
3. Compile an inventory of airport users together
with their requirements for proximity to
Carrboro. Chapel Hill. UNC and Memorial
Hospital.
4. Determine the standards governing the location,
size and operation of an airport. including FAA
and NCDOT rules and regulations. natural
constraints to airport development. and
proximity to existing and proposed residential
and business areas, and major traffic arteries.
5. Determine and put into place a division of
responsibility in planning for airport
relocation as done by the Task Force and
planning for ownership and operation which
should be done by the University of North
Carolina. The latter responsibility should
address:
a. Funding for land acquisition and
construction costs; and
b. Current and anticipated costs involved in
airport operations.
6. Identify any other considerations which the
NCDOT and FAA would like taken into account in
site relocation.
7. Solicit comments and involvement from Chatham
County and Raleigh-Durham Airport.
I
4
theastern in its bid) is superior and the vehicle is similar to those
at are presently in service making it easy to correct electrical
problems and easier for volunteers to use the ambulance. Southeastern
provides fast repair service and replacement parts.
The bids received are listed below:
NAME OF COMPANY NET BID DELIVERY TIME
Ashley Emer. Vehicles $29,545 45-60 Days
Frontline Emer. Vehicles $34,365 60 Days
Southeastern Emer. Equip. $30,865 60 Days
After extended discussion, motion was made by Commissioner Willhoit,
seconded by Commissioner Hartwell to award the bid to Southeastern for a
Frontline ambulance at $30,865. This award is based on the history of
Southeastern providing superior service, both in terms of speed and
quality and on the basis of compatibility of its Frontline vehicle to
other emergency vehicles in the county's fleet which is deemed critical in
part because of the large number of volunteers using the County's ambu-
lance fleet.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS.
1 _ JOINT PLANNING AGREEMENT - CHAPEL HILL
s made the presentation. He presented the revisions
ti rig Agreement with Chapel Hill for consideration of
ag Board recommended approval. The effective date of
Z1 / ;41019 i".7 a the date that the Chapel Hill Land Development
The County will continue to operate under the
1g Agreement until that time.
tde by Commissioner Carey, seconded by Commissioner
te revised Joint Planning Agreement as recommended by
th vvara and to forward the agreement to Chapel Hill for their
approval and upon their approval be signed by both parties.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS.
2. AIRPORT TASK FORCE CHARGE (See corrected copy attached to these
minutes)
August 3, 1987 was set as the due date for the final report to be
presented to the Board.
John Hunter addressed the Board. He commended the Board for
moving forward with the Task Force. He emphasized that- there is a
tremendous need for an airport in this area. He asked that all sides of
the issue be heard. He mentioned that there have been studies that show
the present location to be the best location and he hoped that these
studies would be reviewed. He asked about the composition and suggested
that at least one third of the members have a solid background in aviation
and understand the issues.
After a brief discussion and amendments made to the charge, it was
decided that the charge would be retyped as amended and distributed in an
effort to receive further comments on the charge and also to receive
further recommendations or endorsements of those applications received.
3. INSPECTION FEES (The approved schedule is attached to these
minutes and also in the permanent agenda file in the Clerk's Office)
The presentation was made by Marvin Collins.
Motion was made by Commissioner Carey, seconded by Chair Marshall
to approve the Inspection Fee Schedule as amended.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS.
4. RURAL BUFFER DESIGN STANDARDS STUDY,
PROPOSED ORANGE COUNTY AIRPORT SITES U .
1. CHAPEL HILL TOWNSHIP NORTH OF EUBANKS ROAD BETWEEN 1-40 AND OLD N.C. HIGHWAY 86.
J6INONACHTOWNSHIPDNORTH OF HIGHWAY 54 BETWEEN DODSONS CROSSROADS AND BETHEL■HICKORY
3. BINGHAM TOWNSHIP SOUTH OF GODSONS CROSSROADS BETWEEN DODSONS CROSSROADS SOUTH
AND DAIRYLAND ROAD.
4. CHAPEL HILL TOWNSHIP ■ NORTH OF EUBANKS ROAD BETWEEN 1■40 AND OLD M.C. 86.
j� INGHAN TOWNSHIP • SOUTH OF DAIRYLAND ROAD BETWEEN ORANGE GROVE ROAD AND DODSONS
(,=! CROSSROADS SOUTH.
6. BINGHAM TOWNSHIP — NORTH OF DAIRYLAND ROAD BETWEEN DODSONS CROSSROADS NORTH
AND'ORANGE GROVE ROAD.
45 7. BORDERS CHAPEL HILL AND BINGHAM TOWNSHIP ■ WEST OF OLD N.C. e6 BETWEEN BORLAND
ROAD AND DAVIS ROAD.
47 CHEEKS TOWNSHIP ■ SOUTH OF 1-85 BETWEEN WEST TEN ROAD AND BUSHY COOK ROAD.
GINGHAM TOWNSHIP • NORTH OF N.C. HIGHWAY 54 BETWEEN ORANGE GROVE ROAD AND
` STANFORD ROAD.
45 10. CHEEKS TOWNSHIP • SOUTH OF I■85. BETWEEN CHESTNUT RIDGE ROAD AND ORANGE GROVE
ROAD.
/ '►T CHEEKS TOWNSHIP — SOUTH. OF I■85 BETWEEN BUSHY COOK ROAD AND MT. WILLING ROAD.
12. HILLSBOROUGH TOWNSHIP ■ BETWEEN I■8S AND 1■40 WEST OF N.C. 86.
13. ENO TOWNSHIP ■ NORTH OF I■8S WEST OF PALNERS GROVE ROAD.
14. ENO TOWNSHIP ■ EAST OF PLEASANT GREEN ROAD BETWEEN MILL ROAD AND EBENEZER
CHURCH ROAD.
15. ENO TOWNSHIP BETWEEN ST. MARY+S ROAD AND THE ENO RIVER.
BORDERS LITTLE RIVER TOWNSHIP AND ENO TOWNSHIP BETWEEN SCNLEY ROAD AND WALKER
ROAD:
itilkHILLSBOROUGH TOWNSHIP SOUTH OF PHELPS ROAD BETWEEN N.C. HIGHWAY 86 AND
N.C. HIGHWAY 57.
18. CEDAR GROVE TOWNSHIP EAST OF WALNUT GROVE CHURCH ROAD BETWEEN SCHLEY ROAD
AND PHELPS ROAD.
t4, 19. BORDERS CEDAR GROVE TOWNSHIP AND LITTLE RIVER TOWNSHIP BETWEEN HANKI,NS ROAD
EAST.AND LAWS STORE ROAD.
E, 20. LITTLE RIVER TOWNSHIP ■ NORTH OF N.C. HIGHWAY 57 BETWEEN HOLLY RIDGE ROAD .
AND N.C. HIGHWAY 157.
HORACE WILLIANS AIRP`
jor
PROPOSED ORANGE COUNTY AIRPORT SITES 4
CHAPEL HILL TOWNSHIP NORTH OF EUBANKS ROAD BETWEEN 1-40 AND OLD N.C. HIGHWAY 86.
BINGHAM TOWNSHIP NORTH OF HIGHWAY 54 BETWEEN DODSONS CROSSROADS AND BETHEL-HICKORY
GROVE CHURCH ROAD.
3. BINGHAN TOWNSHIP SOUTH OF DODSONS CROSSROADS BETWEEN DODSONS CROSSROADS SOUTH
AND• DAIRTLAND ROAD.
CHAPEL HILL TOWNSHIP -NORTH OF EUBANKS ROAD BETWEEN 1-40 AND OLD N.C. 86.
60,3 17 5. BINGHAM TOWNSHIP - SOUTH OF DAIRYLAND ROAD BETWEEN ORANGE GROVE ROAD AND DODSONS
CROSSROADS SOUTH.
alpBINGHAM TOWNSHIP - NORTH OF DAIRYLANO ROAD BETWEEN DODSONS CROSSROADS NORTH
AND ORANGE GROVE ROAD.
BORDERS CHAPEL HILL AND BINGHAM TOWNSHIP - WEST OF OLD N.C. 86 BETWEEN BORLAND -
ROAD AND DAVIS ROAD.
y3 8. CHEEKS TOWNSHIP - SOUTH OF 1-85 BETWEEN WEST TEN ROAD AND BUSHY COOK ROAD.
s 6 9. BINGHAM TOWNSHIP - NORTH OF N.C. HIGHWAY 54 BETWEEN ORANGE GROVE ROAD AND
STANFORD ROAD.
a 10. CHEEKS TOWNSHIP - SOUTH OF 1-85 BETWEEN CHESTNUT RIDGE'ROAD .AND ORANGE GROVE
ROAD. •
154.12' 11. CHEEKS TOWNSHIP - SOUTH OF 1-85 BETWEEN BUSHY COOK ROAD AND NT. WILLING ROAD.
OpHILLSBOROUGH TOWNSHIP - BETWEEN 1-85 AND 1-40 WEST OF N.C. 86.
E 13'. ENO TOWNSHIP - NORTH OF 1-85 WEST OF PALMERS GROVE ROAD.
ENO .TOWNSHIP - EAST OF PLEASANT GREEN ROAD BETWEEN MILL ROAD AND EBENEZER
CHURCH ROAD.
ENO TOWNSHIP BETWEEN ST. MARY'S ROAD AND THE ENO RIVER. •
61R, 16. BORDERS LITTLE RIVER TOWNSHIP AND ENO TOWNSHIP BETWEEN SCHLEY ROAD AND WALKER
ROAD.
4� 17. HILLSBOROUGH TOWNSHIP SOUTH OF PHELPS ROAD BETWEEN N.C. HIGHWAY 86 AND
• N.C. HIGHWAY 57.
GED1CEDAR GROVE TOWNSHIP EAST OF WALNUT GROVE CHURCH ROAD BETWEEN SCHLEY ROAD
AND PHELPS ROAD.
EL 19. BORDERS CEDAR GROVE TOWNSHIP AND LITTLE RIVER TOWNSHIP BETWEEN HANKINS ROAD
EAST AND LAWS STORE ROAD.
E, 20. LITTLE RIVER TOWNSHIP - NORTH OF N.C. HIGHWAY $7 BETWEEN HOLLY RIDGE ROAD
AND1N.C. HIGHWAY 157.
HORACE WILLIAMS AIRPORT
g /1 i6 /72 °J--/dtiv
•
•
_ . ...
RIMY
.... ,
. aillr''. •.7 --- len. iti"-"'-'111 - 4
.... - Nvi 4,., f .., ,op,.., , , air.. fi: :; '.ir- • ' • •
i .
, Aiks.,_.',4
T. •-■! A
, .
t r. "
, •
..c, -,... .001
tt . Acolitili,7 ,„,....0 D Lis - _ • / .
2
., ,_ • ..). .., t J.,
... ...„. _ „ . .
4 \..-..,, "•-:., _ ,-,-.'ar ---)rieit---\ '*AllallINWPIPAttv
1 m, Joi --; I
3 tr. • ..........-11111114r•Aiiik,-.• __ –rill,„.....„._ •., . lbw trAN...... _ , . f,.
ilrilikr .'•• *-\. 1 i --
41110.
....
. ....
• '01,-; — - ...„ 1 .
-,,I. - . . ., ,.,.„,, 0. . -w
-r- . , .. : 0 --
IT
i
7-7 "....
.
, , ...,-, . ink, -1.• : .
. ,. . - fc, _ a Walk I' j -f -..-4 , .. .
L '-•.%- c----'.'
.--e - ... 40.:-.'--F LI •...:?..idani., _. A -71fil
_ •
Filk .. lialki.vlingi ...S6-' 4ek.___,...... -• .„ ,..1*7,„ ....,,,.Efj A
:m .q 1111‘..2.72.,7.7-- .. i....710
. 10,‘ • reilla7J)) f 4 1 '' laP fir
...' .,c • •r
dir .... ....4 , ,,, 42/471pr* if.(,• M,' Adi
,
.,10 \ • jeart,d4 1 I
11111bili likiliVI _ _-, ' 'Ina,,, i. , 1 ' (.-4.0-....adr- MC - • h. tl.
1 1. -•'s,
. •‘1,1; '` ''. ; ' . it:. ...1,4"'-f.1" , ./.( , (.., ' ,,.. i . -'
0.0 • ,.. fi ,.-...) .. . 1.1.. _ 1.;_-,..
. . i
1. tr1-
5 1 . . 10, --/ -- - ::■",-„r.--: . ilLi '
I •10/ low ...,,.... .... -
0-6----..hi..„,....." _ ...dallita ...-744:46'.it,,,,,,,,i0ir.„ . 1II. , .. :,...,
.,,,....,......„..____, iv- . to AIM-ALA -,:, ,'"-- 4 i ' .'1 i'l'• 1.1 4
fillie. r:?-77- 4-7"11)." ' ' ..t t al.r--...Asigip ---aL ' '- ---- • .
41'--
,41111L 1 --r.-.......74qt....,,--,,,,x,:14 .1.1%.-.ion.r....114a6 ' .. •.' .
vi•-- ;,-.: ' ---—00.0&-."
;iv,,,,,,;-..--f4110. ...L., -71111,..1■11,;,:ailLAIII. rqtki.i....LIAli 0\ , ......., ' . .. 74.....ire
1 , 1 k :).:7L-,„a'irtili:t. olrfilp___)7).2,,li7ti,IP44741-r4.114 IlF4%:-Y...!..7";_:t.:440.11tr„,...wir:,,..42•,_':141r$74r.a_c•Iiii_.. ' 11- - itil-
. ,. ,„ ,_Alt'• •al r ".:1-4 :. - - ''''717111L 1114Z411N12 mli■7-. Aho. 13, -..„,
. _ .
6 c.. ',..t•-;„--k
I: I'
, ).7,41041 110 P.1(.„..--,s:■••• „ )10- • „....1 A irAlr4-'"MOIlii
tt. - .3.:41046---.‘ Atoomm.............:..- -.'-'-',„,
oillorPr'Ir , ir. 4014 ., I,. . ,...
i:
_......, 4.
'd, k'
- ■' ; Ail
.. .., -. • ' , % 7 • 4.
7 1, ,.., , ,1
., _ I .., .. . •
,
1
i•,— s,.! I L ' ti I AnitiElaille110 ..4*. 'alet.' .''-',-1110.1"ee...41116.. i ' 6simi Er
, ._.
".".1
,.... r
Fir' I
8 1 -.. tw. .N) 6 ■,, 7 ' it, ink \ :k. -;;V111:44, -
Orm a
.--rOM 441.0 ,KA, '4111111 VIII6-41111,ON■ IP. 1
, i ......„.
9,0 . , ..: T. / , , ‘ . , .... ,,,,,_,...„;lib L A ,.,....„. g i•
-•-• 06. I..-.,,,i s-')' -",;:. ..,....... . ..i 17_IP
I it- I. r..',r..&)\.401i..5.'. . ‘.-.1'"■.re 1 'V.III,I I LI10111 C 1 0 r 1---A-1 I IP". ' Allfrt#414 1
)11
• .rkt pitilf4 , lc
44111L 6r-
itripb..in i . .
V k
, .
„... ....;
.. „,. :
1 "msw,:110 .r-,.., r,"7"1:7-ct .-.' telkow"erlir!kCallefiAl tat I
• r
0 -- A 1 II . hfr "
I- Afar l 7 ' vezte -4):/ 4 lligh.tt.1:-. .
- ,- ,... • , ' ;
...Fe.
s"-71.- . til '‘''Piti.7 -1: ir.r •
t in
gi ' rie.4t: Al LA" n.
ORANGE COON Y ROAD MAP 2c...PaeffigEEL (A.
roma r no croon oar,rarer or ...PO.11I
...... -
.., r
p.n. tr*
r ... .10 ?4
1 AL., ,41 , , • ,..., ..: .,„.... 4., miar .... , do
,.
,.ir• Q
.' , ,
1,..‹. ,-,*( . .,... 114 VI WM.44 .‹. 1 ,10 Ike" ' "fir,411110014
■,...,,-° I. 1' \"■', f Aciie- bid - .-Krim -‘," 09 A. _. , 7 .
2 : jfir it# ''''tv_i r.74,11. . cd,.. , ,44116iiiiii,5
• ,E,.. • -.........., ......... _ ........ • •,, ....r....... _ . a fir-Alm■• .-------
ixrp-Air.; -111 `. t - '.--‹ tx-r , • ..,' I'llgrallitirfilli
emir• , --"'. w. . ,.
3 Talton ... .,_
, 4.:„ - e /*-,' ? " i .. : i` ---' zy,'''r -4 ' • i:,;-*/
;- , i 4 iss, Art- , ../ ....
_
AA-- f „,....m.,,,
-,4,ri - iirstisAlve--- riii,V1111(14 .._4!,.F.!-Jpr:i,370
4 1111111019allagini.7. At Olt Illr rj 116
;,. . I lif'r f • ' " ' `
riy, r .q
d / 411■14fir t , - tuark,„„.„. ....5. : f
lk 4 -lig:
-- 1. ....imaiw_. __ ., i *.::itilL811' Adi° , i s•reloirea, -- t 1,_. r.
. . , .--vm lipc.., „Now.? I i,.. r - i._ r,ir, ...1,.. • 1-:.
I
.7 • 111111 oito./ 's ;' -. 1, ..,..f 1 - r. . Li:.
Su or
7:- 1/010 -
i r ,
-----•-. r.
i .. .411111M
,-I
1 ,,w
if
liprZhar_........ .C., ..,.. Am..._ . •
:-.1t1..•, ipr-.,A .., •`-..-- ,
VIM! .. 101111111.- -c__.; •14-4-6.......---10 -"....v...., ....34-1L. r- ---- --' 44- r ...7 iii,„,
lor.,.... .......f„,a---* . 71,04,4-1, 1*-iirstir.g, AV .
-. 4.1...I
11111. erj r"*"... 1 W.. VIIIIN__ ..1116.1r;
„d . . '47) I ' . '- - "."'"ii.L, 1■10-Siol- "-^.41/411i
6t * ' , ri bik,....v.4r Aiti ,..,- 4/Fizji
,- • '--*.= -, ' 4/ '''.- -,..;.Vp•--,-,$' -- . ' r . ,.....
1 - ,,.. 01-fr..* _,-,---<:
4.0. ,
: : - v., _.„.„ • . mil
11 1 lieh . ••• ..-
- )
I ......--- 000, A; / ... - ' i , '116, Algru. ..AffitimirhQZ‘,..... .-'---.74`--7.t L ••
1 reiar u .
Al ., — — - • . °lPl,P°"'"'''-
\ IN ■ ”
7 Ur WV.44 0 .7:
i , /"••••• , ' AldOP 4 , 1 t 1"i- •
s • ......._ 1 _ \.._ r i , . . ' .
.1/4.
7
• , ' - Atr 7
_ 1 _ j. / , ,. , .
diliviailll=. ° '$"/ it
do .- 4117;vrida
-44N-awiem swo
wir
,t4 \-.) , .....-„ . -oze, if ..4■1&.50.4.4
te li
rillati ._._ 1316,11401, s lit.: 41111,471116. 41___ail.4141_114N_401'..... ,4
.....E.•■
1
• liplOrk I, 1410/ '1.1-- -arif:
Ikelij
liailvii,„. .,i4tr , low .4.4 .-.. 151.11447.- iroti i
EL as-
.. .=.7....
?;:... M41111■Y AL;
"i-,9911-1111111 OPYM.77 re, , •1,, iiiik"rill*--vraFinifi ,1
1 r; 7 ;,....‘. ,. ) , . -L--,), 11 .•ae-- logra..411.vm • Iti4
_ • ...4s k\...... ,...„.
F ran. i
10 ir
1 -- --il
IIP .- y -- •,' E. ,..w.1)-' ‘...;:***----40v? -4.11.41.' 11, - r
y 1 1
• ,''' Atli( _ __, s : _. ,-.1-0, .--4.?.4 atight,,.....1---,. I
.7. ,
AV
IP
1
c..... G., ,................ iii.... ..,. Aw„,, ti___ I.
, _......,
ORANGE COUNTY ROAD MAP
er...Fsims. ta.*
. I ___.
\