Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutORD-2016-004 Ordinance Amending the UDO in order to adopt regulations governing the location and development of sexually oriented businesses p1F 5b )rdinance#:2016-004 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ORANGE COUNTY UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT ORDINANCE WHEREAS, Orange County has initiated amendment(s) to the Orange County Unified Development Ordinance in order to adopt regulations governing the location and development of sexually oriented businesses, and WHEREAS, numerous studies, most notably: a. A 2013 study for Louisville Kentucky by Eric S. McCord and Richard Tewksbury; A 2011 study entitled The ASSOCIATION of Adult Businesses with Secondary Effects: Legal Doctrine, Social Theory, and b. Empirical Evidence authored by Alan C. Weinstein and Richard McCleary; and c. A 1996 report completed by the American Center for Law and Justice have indicated sexually oriented businesses support detrimental activities (i.e. personal and property crimes, prostitution, drugs, etc.) within the vicinity of their operation(s) that are incompatible with activities occurring within residential areas, and have a negative impact on local businesses, and WHEREAS, these same studies indicate there is evidence when sexually oriented businesses are located near each other and/or near businesses that serve alcohol, identified secondary impacts are increased, and WHEREAS, A 2005 report completed by Duncan and Associates for Kenton and Campbell Counties in Kentucky, as well as the Northern Kentucky Area Planning Commission, found that: A governmental body's key purpose in regulating sexually oriented businesses is to mitigate the negative secondary effects. One of the easiest ways is to ensure that the sexually oriented businesses are located away from the types of land uses on which they are most likely to have adverse secondary effects. Zoning is the classic tool for regulating the locations of various uses and for ensuring that uses that are incompatible are kept reasonably separate, and WHEREAS, the courts have consistently found local communities have the legal ability and interest in promoting stable neighborhoods through requiring setbacks and limiting the operational parameters of sexually oriented businesses to address identified secondary impacts, and WHEREAS, the courts have found local communities have the legal ability to restrict or prohibit the consumption/sale of alcohol at sexually oriented businesses to address identified secondary impacts, and WHEREAS, the County has determined the secondary effects of sexually oriented businesses have negative secondary impacts on the surrounding area, which will be addressed by the proposed regulations. 1 WHEREAS, the County has found the proposed text amendments to be reasonably necessary to promote public health, safety and general welfare and to achieve the purposes of the adopted Comprehensive Plan, and WHEREAS, the requirements of Section 2.8 of the Unified Development Ordinance have been deemed complete, and WHEREAS, pursuant to North Carolina General Statute 153A-341 and Section 1.1.7 of the Unified Development Ordinance, the Board of Commissioners of Orange County has found the proposed text amendments to be consistent with the goals and policies of the adopted Comprehensive Plan. BE IT ORDAINED by the Board of Commissioners of Orange County that the Unified Development Ordinance of Orange County is hereby amended as depicted in the attached pages. BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED that this ordinance be placed in the book of published ordinances and that this ordinance is effective upon its adoption. x Upon motion of Comrtiissioner , seconded by Commissioner - _° : , the foregoing ordinance was adopted this _al_ day of ff�_ ., ��„ , 2016. I, Donna S. Baker, Clerk to the Board of Commissioners for Orange County, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing is a true copy of so much of the proceedings of said Board at a meeting held on p2., /,b , 2016 as relates in any way to the adoption of the foregoing and that said proceedings are recorded in the minutes of the said Board. WITNESS my hand and the seal of said County, this ) day of .41. ,=, d,,,... 2016. iiriFq / ip 17 Ej{ oxio 0 ' Tp� 5z ` / .711# tat to UDO AMENDMENT PACKET NOTES: The following packet details staff's proposed modifications to existing regulations associated with the review and permitting of sexually oriented businesses. As the number of affected pages/sections of the existing UDO are being modified with this proposal staff has divided the proposed amendments into the following color coded classifications: • Red Underlined Text: Denotes new, proposed text, that staff is suggesting be added to the UDO • Red Strikethrough Text: Denotes existing text that staff is proposing to delete • Green Bold Underlined Text: Denotes new, proposed text, designed to address comments made at the November 23, 2015 Quarterly Public Hearing. • Purple Bold Underlined Text: Denotes new, proposed text, designed to address comments made by the County Attorney's office after agenda review held on January 20, 2016. Staff has included footnotes within the amendment package to provide additional information/rationale concerning the proposed amendments to aid in your review. Only those pages of the UDO impacted by the proposed modification(s) have been included within this packet. Some text on the following pages has a large "X" through it to denote that these sections are not part of the amendments under consideration. The text is shown only because in the full UDO it is on the same page as text proposed for amendment or footnotes from previous sections `spill over' onto the included page. Text with a large "X" is not proposed for deletion. Please note that the page numbers in this amendment packet may or may not necessarily correspond to the page numbers in the adopted UDO because adding text may shift all of the text/sections downward. Users are reminded that these excerpts are part of a much larger document (the UDO) that regulates land use and development in Orange County. The full UDO is available online at: http://www.orangecountync.gov/departments/planning and inspections/UDO MOST CURRE NT updated 120915.pdf Article 5: Uses Section 5.2:Table of Permitted Uses II - S - ''SS . �; GENERAL USE ZONING DISTRICTS USE TYPE RB AR R1 R2 R3 R4 R5 R8 R13 LC1 NC2 CC3 GC4 EC5 01 AS El 11 12 13 PID Use may not be •- mitted as a Conditional Use District; -- ection 5.1.4(E) ^Allowed as more than one p .aI use if located on a .• . fide farm (see Section 6.2.5) Repair Service Electronic&Appliance . * * * Restaurants: Carry Out Restaurants: Drive In * * Restaurants: General * * Retail, Class 1 * Retail, Class 2 Retail, Class 3 Rural Guest Estab ent: Bed & Breakfast" * * * Rural G -- stablishment: Bed& Breakfast Inn^ B B -.ral Guest Establishment: Country Inn" A A * * I Sexually Oriented Businesses' • ..e of Goods, Outdoor * * * * Storage or Ware •. '••. Inside Building * * * * * * Studio(Art) * * * * * * * * Taxidermy^ - * * * * Tourist Home `� * * * * Wholesale Trade Winery with Minor Events" B B B B B EXTRACTIVE USE on of Earth Products- A A A 1 Staff is recommending the uses be allowed in our medium and heavy industrial districts as a permitted use of property. This is due to the lack of identified sensitive uses(i.e. residential,schools,church,etc.)typically found in those areas of the County where large scale industrial/manufacturing operations are intended for development. Orange County, North Carolina-Unified Development Ordinance Page 5-7 Article 5: Uses Section 5.6: Standards for Commercial Uses from adjacent residentially zoned property. (4) The site shall be located on a major road, as classified in the Or- ge County Comprehensive Plan, unless permitted as an ASE-CZ. (5) 'arking shall not be located in the front yard space. (6) App ation materials shall include a comprehens. - groundwater study, for facilities : pected to use more groundwater o• -n annual basis than an average single famil -sidence (which uses 240 •_ ons of water per day) built at the highest density -- existing zoning dis t would allow For example, if the existing zoning distr. allows a res 2ential density of 1 unit for 2 acres and the proposed use is on a si -cre •- cel (which could yield 3 residences), the proposed use(s) may use t -e times the water used by an average single family residence (or 720 gallo - per d-, on an annualized basis) before a comprehensive gro -dwater study I equired. The water usage rates of any existing use sub.- t to zoning regulato ocated on the same lot shall be taken into account en determining if a compreh- •sive groundwater study is required. Said stu• shall detail: (a) The amount of water anticipated to be used o - daily, weekly, monthly, and annual basis by regulated uses located on th- •arcel (e.g., water usage by bona fide farm uses is not required to be inc .•ed), (b) An analysis of the amount of groundwater withdrawal consi•: ed to be safe and sustainable in the immediate vicinity; and (c) An analysis of whether other wells in the vicinity of the proposed use - - expected to be affected by withdrawals made by the proposed use. 5.6.15 Sexually Oriented Businesses (A) Submittal Requirements (1) In addition to the site plan submittal criteria detailed within Section 2.5 of this Ordinance the applicant shall submit proof a license has been issued allowing2for the operation of a sexually oriented business in accordance with Chapter 8 of the Orange County Code of Ordinances. (B) Standards of Evaluation (1) Sexually oriented business(es) shall not be located in any building, or portion thereof, that is: (a) Within 1,000 feet of an existing sexually oriented business. (b) Within 1,000 feet of a: (i) Residential land use including any open space established as part of the residential subdivision approval process, (ii) Church and/or place of worship, (iii) School (public, private, or specialty), (iv) Public or private library, (v) State licensed child care facility, or (vi) Public park or recreational facility. (c) Measurement shall be made in a straight line, without regard to the intervening structures or objects, from the nearest portion of the building or structure used as the part of the premises where a sexually oriented 2 Purple Bold Underlined text added to address County Attorney's comment from staff agenda review held on January 20, 2016. Orange County, North Carolina—Unified Development Ordinance Page 5-62 Article 5: Uses Section 5.7: Standards for Recreational Uses business is conducted to the nearest portion of a building, structure, or open space area of a use listed above. SECTION 5.7: STANDARDS FOR RECREATIONAL USES 5. 1 Recreational Facilities (A) General Standards of Evaluation (1) The standards included herein shall be applied to the following for-profit recreational facilities. (a) Tennis clubs, (b) Swim clubs, (c) Racquet ball, (d) Squash clubs, (e Pitch and putt courses, (f) Amusement areas, (g) :owling alleys, (h) Skating rinks, (I) Shoo g ranges, (j) Billiard a•d pool halls, (k) Indoor athle .c facilities an. (I) Other similar u•es. (2) The minimum lot area sha b- two acres. (3) No building shall be closer h.n the minimum requirements of the district or 20 feet to the public right of ay o .rivate property line, whichever is greater. (B) Standards for Class B Spe .'.l Use Per 't (1) Submittal Requir- ents In addition to th- information required b Section 2.7, the following information shall be supp.-d as part of the application or approval of this use: (a) A .-scription of the exact type facilit slanned, the amount of area, i'cluding and number of members or p. icipants expected, a site plan showing siting and size of existing and p sosed building. (b) Access, parking, service and recreation are for all planned facilities or existing facilities. c) Plans, and elevation for all proposed and existin. tructures and descriptions of the color and nature of all exterior :terials. (d) A landscape plan showing, at the same scale as the s .- plan, existing and proposed trees, shrubs, ground cover and any othe andscape materials. (e) A signed statement from the owners or operators that there shall be no activity allowed that will have adverse effects on adjacent prop- y The statement shall also include a complete list of all recreational acts' ties that will take place on the site (2) Standards of Evaluation Orange County, North Carolina—Unified Development Ordinance Page 5-63 ARTICLE 8: NONCONFORMITIES SECTION 8.1: INTENT 8.1.1 Generally Non-conforming uses shall not be enlarged, expanded, intensified, or altered, except in conformance with this Ordinance. It is further the intent of this Ordinance that non-conformity shall not be used as grounds for adding other prohibited uses or structures, nor the enlarging by means of extension or expansion, except as specifically provided by this Ordinance. In the case of requirements related to external factors, such as distance requirements from other specified uses or landscaping requirements dependent upon adiacent property use, the subiect parcel shall be considered conforming so long as its continuous use was established first.3 SECTION 8.2: CLASSIFICATION Non-conformities are classified as: ) Lots (see Section 8.7); (B) Uses of land without structures or minor structures (see Section 8 8); (C) .ses of major structures and premises (see Section 8.9); (D) Strut ures (see Section 8.10); and/or (E) Charact- 'stirs of uses (see Section 8.11) which were lawful bu ould be prohibited, regulated, or restrict;s by the enactment of this Ordinance or a subsequ: t amendment thereto. SECTION 8.3: COMPLE i!ON OF NON-CONFORMING PROJECTS 8.3.1 Valid Permit Issued All non-conforming projects on which c.. in was begun at least 180 days before the effective date of this Ordinance, or any m.. cation thereto, as well as all non-conforming projects that are at least 25% completed to s of the total expected cost of the project on the effective date of this Ordinance, or any odifica ••n thereto, may be completed in accordance with the terms of their permits, so lo►• as these pe its were validly issued and remain unrevoked and unexpired. If a development is design:d to be completed in stages, this subsection shall only apply to -e particular phase unde onstruction. (A) Except as provide. his Section, all work on any non onforming project shall cease on the effective da - of this Ordinance, or any modification ereto, and all permits previously is .ed for work on non-conforming projects sha be revoked as of that date. Thereafter ork on non-conforming projects may begin or m. be continued only pursua o a zoning or special use permit issued in accordance ith this Ordinance by the P .nning Director or board authorized to issue permits for the t •e of development pre.osed. The county shall issue such a permit if it finds that the app• ant has in good :ith made substantial expenditures or incurred substantial binding oblig. •ons in some substantial way in reasonable reliance on conditions as they existed before e effective date of this Ordinance, or any modification thereto, and thereby would be unre: onably prejudiced if not allowed to complete the project as proposed. In considering wh- er these findings may be made, the Planning Director or appropriate board shall be gu zed by the following: 3 Language added to address situations where legal land uses are made nonconforming by external forces. By adding the language the land use will still be considered a legal,conforming, use of property. Orange County, North Carolina—Unified Development Ordinance Page 8-1 ARTICLE 10: DEFINITIONS SECTION 10.1: DEFINITIONS For the pu •- e of this Ordinance, certain terms and words are herein defined and inte : eted as follows: AASHTO American Association of State Hig', - and Transportation Offic - . Accessory Structure A structure that is located on the same lot as a . ci.. tructure and houses an accessory use. Accessory Use An activity that may or may not •- isted in the Permitted Use Table, wh • is conducted in conjunction with a permitted principal :-, but constitutes only an incidental or insubstanti- •art of the total activity that takes place on t - of and is customary and ancillary to the established princip- e of property. Accessory uses - all comply with all setback requirements for the district in which the us- located. For example, .• -ground swimming pool is required to meet all applicable setbacks including any -:uired fenci • .round the physical pool, the concrete walkway around the pool, and any pump or utilities ociated with the operation of the facility. Adult Uses An establishment which has a majority of its business which excludes minors by r anon of age because Adult Arcade Any place to which the public is permitted or invited wherein coin-operated or slug-operated or electronically, electrically, or mechanically controlled still or motion picture machines, protectors, or other image-producing devices are maintained to show images to five or fewer persons per machine at any one time, and where the images so displayed are distinguished or characterized by the depicting or describing of Specified Sexual Activities or Specified Anatomical Areas. Adult Bookstore A bookstore: (a) Which receives a majority of its gross income during any calendar month from the sale or rental of publications (including books, magazines, other periodicals, videotapes, compact discs, other photographic, electronic, magnetic, digital, or other imaging medium) which are distinguished or characterized by their emphasis on matter depicting, describing, or relating to Specified Sexual Activities or Specified Anatomical Areas, as defined in this article; or (b) Having as a preponderance (either in terms of the weight and importance of the material or in terms of greater volume of materials) of its publications (including books, magazines, other periodicals, videotapes, compact discs, other photographic, electronic, magnetic, digital, or other imaging medium) which are distinguished or characterized by their emphasis on matter depicting, describing, or relating to Specified Sexual Activities or Specified Anatomical Areas. Adult Cabaret A nightclub, bar, restaurant, theater, concert hall, auditorium or similar commercial establishment that for at least ten percent of its business hours in any day features: (a) Persons who expose a Specified Anatomical Area; or (b) Live performances that are characterized by the exposure of Specified Anatomical Areas or by Specified Sexual Activities; or Article 10: Definitions Section 10.1: Definitions (c) Films, motion pictures, video cassettes, slides, or other photographic reproductions that are characterized by the depiction or description of Specified Sexual Activities or Specified Anatomical Areas; or (d) Persons who engage in lewd, lascivious or erotic dancing or performances that are intended for the sexual interests or titillation of an audience or customers. Adult Escort A person who, for consideration, agrees or offers to act as a companion, guide, or date for another person for the purpose of participating in, engaging in, providing, or facilitating Specified Sexual Activities. Adult Escort Agency A person or business that furnishes, offers to furnish, or advertises to furnish adult escorts as one of its business purposes for a fee, tip, or other consideration. Adult Merchandise Any product dealing in or with explicitly sexual material as characterized by matter depicting, describing, or relating to Specified Sexual activities or Specified Anatomical Areas. Adult Motel A hotel, motel or similar commercial establishment that offers accommodation to the public for any form of consideration and: (a) Provides patrons with closed-circuit television transmissions, films, motion pictures, video cassettes, slides, or other photographic reproductions that are characterized by the depiction or description of Specified Sexual Activities or Specified Anatomical Areas; and has a sign visible from the public rights-of-way that advertises the availability of this adult type of photographic reproductions; or (b) Offers a sleeping room for rent for a period of time that is less than six hours; or (c) Allows a tenant or occupant of a sleeping room to subrent the room for a period of time that is less than twelve hours. Adult Patron Any person who is physically present on the premises of a sexually oriented business and who is not an owner, employee, agent, subcontractor, or independent contractor of said business, or any entertainer or performer at said business. Adult Video Store A commercial establishment that, as one of its principal business purposes, offers for sale or rental for any form of consideration any one or more of the following: books, magazines, periodicals or other printed matter, or photographs, films, motion picture, video tapes or cassettes, video reproductions, CD-ROMs, slides, or other visual representations which depict or describe Specified Sexual Activities or Specified Anatomical Areas; or any combination thereof. Ag tural Processing Facility, Community A facility utiliz-: •r the processing of produce and/or other commodities produce. o more than 5 cooperative farm pa - or the consumption of others (e.g. small canni • •aeration); Activities shall include, but may not be limite• ., -nning, dehydrations, washin• -• ing or basic preparation of raw produce but does not include processin• : .ve animals =- V eat Processing Facility). May include accessory retail sales of products processed on- Agricultural Processin• - ity A facility utilized for the • . essing and packaging of produce and/or other c. - edifies for transport to off-site wholes- - • retail establishments. Facilities may be utilized by farm-based pr.._ -rs, restaur- -• s, caterers, food entrepreneurs, and the like. Activities shall include, but may not 1- .44 ited to, ing, dehydrations, washing, cutting or basic preparation of raw produce prior to shipment but does Orange County, North Carolina—Unified Development Ordinance Page 10-2 Article 10: Definitions Section 10.1: Definitions customary accessories, orna - , . - _ - -is lands -•••• --- •- •-rmi ed in any setback if they do not constitute substantial • •-,"••-- • ee ow of light an. .• - •- - •ack or violate provisions • ---- • • er regulations regarding visibility. Sexually Oriented Devices Any artificial or simulated Specified Anatomical Area or other device or paraphernalia that is designed principally for Specified Sexual Activities but shall not mean any contraceptive device. Sexually Oriented Business A business which offers its customers or adult patrons any device, activity or demonstration depicting Specified Sexual Activities , or which is intended to appeal to sexual interests, titillation or arousal of the customer or adult patron. A sexually oriented business shall include an adult establishment as in NCGS 14-202.10(2) and, in addition, without limitation shall include: Adult Arcade, Adult Bookstore, Adult Video Store, Adult Cabaret, Adult Motel, and Adult Escort Agency. Sign A letter, figure, character, mark, plane, point, marquee, design, poster, pictorial, picture, str e, stripe, line, :•emark, reading matter, or illuminated surface which is constructed, placed, attach:., painted, erected, -,tened or manufactured in any manner so that the same shall be used for th- attraction of the public to any . .ce, subject, person, firm, corporation, public performance, article, .chine, or merchandise, wh •4 are displayed in any manner, including out-of-doors. Sign, Abandoned A sign for which no legal own- an be found or any sign face or sig ructure that advertises a business not conducted on the premises to •ver 90 days In making the d- -rmination that a sign advertises a business no longer being conducted, - Planning Director sh-. consider the following: the existence or absence of a current occupational license, tility service d=•osit, or account; use of the premises; and relocation of the business. Abandoned Sign shall also include the following: a) Through age and/or obsolescence a si•• a' •• longer conforms to structural or maintenance specifications of Section 6.12, or b) Any pole, pylon, or structure expr- sly installed for th- •urpose of affixing a sign that bears no sign or copy. Sign, Advertiser Any person who is a Jesse= or owner of a sign, an agent of same, or anyone t• -t has beneficial use of a sign. Sign, Adve ing Display Area The adverti • g display surface area encompassed within any polygon that would enclose all p.fi s of the sign. T - structural supports for a sign, whether, they be columns, pylons, or a building, or a part -reof, shall ••t be included in the advertising area Also known as Sign Area. • An example of how advertising display area or sign area is calculated is as follows: Orange County, North Carolina—Unified Development Ordinance Page 10-39 Article 10: Definitions Section 10.1: Definitions •ecial Event A c•• mercial activity attracting at least 20 people at any given time, that typically does no .nvolve perman_ t structures, and does not occur more frequently than seven days in a 30-da •eriod or more than 50 da, per year. Examples of special events are craft shows, small festivals oncerts, medical or veterinary climb , and sites operated by businesses engaged in hosting outdoor social events such as picnics or recepti•• sponsored by a restaurant or caterer. Activities which are n• included in this definition include: a) Events of a pers••al or non-profit, nature such as family reun't s and church activities; b) Farm-related or rura -vents such as horse shows, 4-H ev= s and auctions; and c) Fund-raising events for -•n-profit organizations. Special Flood Hazard Area (S - A ) The land in the floodplain subject to a 1% • •reater • ance of being flooded in any given year as determined in Section 4.3 of this Ordinance, a •- fined by the base flood elevation. The mapped special flood hazard area approximates the base floo• el- -tion. Special Flood Hazard Area Ov lay District An overlay district establishing sta •ards for development fo .roperties within identified floodplains. Special-Purpose Uni • Government Any special district or p . is authority Special Use A use which , •uld not be appropriate generally throughout the zoning district or wi •ut special study, but which, if c► trolled as to number, area, location or relation to neighborhood, would be appropriate. Such uses -ich are listed as Special Uses in the Permitted Use Table, Section 5 2, may be ins : led and op-'-ted only after approval by the Board of Commissioners or by the Board of Adjustment, a -•propriate, subject to the general and specific standards. Specified Anatomical Areas (a) Less than completely and opaquely covered human: (i) genitals, pubic region, (ii) buttocks, or(Hi) female breast below a point immediately above the top of the areola; or (b) Human male genitals in a discernibly turgid state, even if completely and opaquely covered. Specified Sexual Activities (a) Human genitals in a state of sexual stimulation or arousal; (b) Acts of human masturbation, sexual intercourse or sodomy; or (c) Fondling or other erotic touchings of human genitals, pubic regions, buttocks or female-breasts. rt of Construction Inclu•-• ubstantial improvement, and means the date the building permit was issued, provided t - actual start • onstruction, repair, reconstruction, rehabilitation, addition placement, or othe improvement was , hin 180 days of the permit date. The actual start means either t - rst placement of permanent construction . a structure (including a manufactured home) on a sit-, uch as the pouring of slabs or footings, installation • •iles, construction of columns, or any wor. •-yond the stage of excavation; or the placement of a - ufactured home on a founda . Permanent construction does not include land preparation, such as cleari •, •rading, and fillin• -•r does it include the installation of streets and/or walkways; nor does it include e.--vation a basement, footings, piers, or foundations or the erection of temporary forms; nor does it inclu•- - installation on the property of accessory buildings, such as garages or sheds not occupied as • .- ling units : not part of the main structure. For a substantial improvement, the actual - of construction mean 4e first alteration of any wall, ceiling, floor, or other structural part of • - •uilding, whether or not that alter- .•n affects the external dimensions of the building. State A• - • Ever --partment, agency, institution, public authority, board, commission, bureau, division, -•uncil, -mber of Council of State, or officer of the State government of the State of North Carolina. Orange County, North Carolina—Unified Development Ordinance Page 10-51