HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 20061204
APPROVED 1121312007
MINUTES
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
REGULAR MEETING
December 4, 2006
7:30 p.m.
The Orange County Board of Commissioners met in regular session on Monday,
December 4, 2006 at 7:30 p.m. in the F. Gordon Battle Courtroom in Hillsborough, North
Carolina.
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Chair Moses Carey, Jr. and Commissioners
Valerie P. Foushee, Alice M. Gordon, Barry Jacobs, and Mike Nelson
COUNTY ATTORNEYS PRESENT: Geoffrey Gledhill
COUNTY STAFF PRESENT: County Manager Laura Blackmon, Assistant County
Managers Rod Visser and Gwen Harvey, and Clerk to the Board Donna S. Baker (All other staff
members will be identified appropriately below)
NOTE: ALL DOCUMENTS REFERRED TO IN THESE MINUTES ARE IN THE PERMANENT
AGENDA FILE IN THE CLERK'S OFFICE. ALL RECORDINGS OF THE MEETING WILL BE
KEPT FOR 5 YEARS.
Resolution of Commendation for Commissioner Stephen H. Halkiotis
A motion was made by Commissioner Gordan, seconded by Commissioner Carey to
approve a resolution of commendation for Commissioner Stephen H. Halkiotis.
Chair Jacobs read the resolution (stated below):
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
RESOLUTION OF COMMENDATION
FOR
COMMISSIONER STEPHEN H. HALKIOTIS
WHEREAS, Stephen Halkiotis was inspired to run for public office after he encountered
injustice and the arbitrary exercise of power, serendipitously at a time when the
Board of County Commissioners needed more progressive voices; and
WHEREAS, the citizens of Orange County elected Stephen Halkiotis to the Board of County
Commissioners in 1986 and re-elected him in 1990, 1994, 1998, and 2002; and,
WHEREAS, his Board colleagues expressed recognition of, and appreciation for, Stephen
Halkiotis' service and leadership by electing him as Chair of the Board of
Commissioners in 2001 and as Vice-Chair for 14 years, most recently in 2005-
06; and
WHEREAS, Stephen Halkioitis has served the citizens of Orange County for many years, not
only as a County Commissioner but also as the principal of Orange High School
and later as Director of Auxiliary Services for the Orange County Schools
system; and
WHEREAS, Commissioner Halkiotis has given freely and unselfishly of his time and energy,
and through his foresight and leadership, he helped promote progressive
changes and improvements in the operations and services of Orange County
government; and
WHEREAS, during his tenure as an Orange County Commissioner, Stephen Halkiotis has
shared his talent for leadership and public service through his work on numerous
committees, boards, and task forces including the Mental Health Board (OPC),
two Innovation and Efficiency Committees, the Landfill Owners Group, the
Partnership for Young Children, the Energy Task Group, several bond
committees, design committees for the Seymour and Central Orange Senior
Centers, the Durham Technical Community College Satellite Campus Advisory
Committee and the Hillsborough Economic Development District Work Group,
among others; and
WHEREAS, Commissioner Halkiotis embodies the slogan "You Count in Orange County", his
genuine concern far others manifest through his tireless advocacy for children,
the disadvantaged, and the downtrodden; and
WHEREAS, there comes a time when a person must recognize that "life is too short" and
adjust priorities accordingly;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Orange County Board of Commissioners
officially commends Stephen H. Halkiotis for his years of distinguished service,
salutes his voluntary decision to leave public office, looks forward to his
continued contributions to the community, and wishes him and his family the very
best in their future endeavors.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this resolution be presented to Mr. Halkiotis, with a copy sent
to the press, and that the Resolution be spread upon the minutes of this meeting.
This the fourth day of December 2006.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
Commissioner Halkiotis wished everyone all the best and encouraged the County
Commissioners to continue to do this with a sense of humor and not to take it too seriously,
because life is too short.
Oaths of Office for Board Members
Judge Joe Buckner administered the oaths of office for Commissioner Gordan,
Commissioner Jacobs. and Commissioner Nelson.
Board Organization
a. Election of Chair and Vice-Chair
Commissioner Carey -Chair {unanimous}
Commissioner Jacobs -Vice-Chair {4 votes}
b. Designation of Voting Delegate far all NCACC and NACo meetings for Calendar
Year December 1, 2006-2007
A motion was made by Commissioner Gordon, seconded by Commissioner Foushee to
appoint Commissioner Carey as the Voting Delegate for all NCACC and NACa meetings for
Calendar Year December 1, 2006-2007.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
Appointments
a. Manager
A motion was made by Commissioner Gordon, seconded by Commissioner Jacobs to
appoint Laura Blackmon as County Manager.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
b. Clerk to the Board
A motion was made by Commissioner Gordon, seconded by Commissioner Foushee to
appoint Donna Baker as Clerk to the Board.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
e. County Attorney
A motion was made by Commissioner Foushee, seconded by Commissioner Gordon to
appoint Geof Gledhill as County Attorney.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
PUBLIC CHARGE
The Chair dispensed wifh the reading of the public charge.
1. Additions or Changes to the Agenda
NONE
2. Public Comments
a. Matters not on the Printed Agenda
NONE
b. Matters on the Printed Agenda
{These matters were considered when the Board addressed that item on the agenda
below.}
3. Board Comments
Commissioner Nelson thanked the people of Orange County for electing him to this
position. He said that he has come to know so much more about the County through the
campaign and he would like to work on taxes, technology for the County, environmental uses
and energy efficiency, and library services. He said that he is committed to following through
with the Library Task Force recommendations. He would also like to establish a library in the
southwestern portion of the County {Carrboro).
Commissioner Foushee welcomed new County Manager Laura Blackmon and thanked
Rod Visser for being Interim Manager. She also welcomed Commissioner Nelson.
Commissioner Foushee said that she attended the initial meeting of the Eno EDD Small
Area Task Force. The meeting was very productive. There were officials from Durham City to
help with the planning. She said that there are several positions on this task force that are
vacant, and four are at-large positions. She encouraged anyone interested in this task force to
apply.
Commissioner Foushee made reference to the County Commissioners' meeting
agendas and suggested moving Board comments to another portion of the agenda, perhaps at
the end, because many times the agenda is ambitious and the special presentations are very
late.
Commissioner Jacobs welcomed Commissioner Nelson and Laura Blackmon.
Commissioner Jacobs agreed with taking up the issue brought up by Commissioner
Foushee, and he suggested addressing it at the retreat. He said that Andy Sachs from the
Dispute Settlement Center is supposed to meet with the Board between the last meeting and
the retreat to flesh out the issues far the retreat.
Commissioner Jacobs reported that Rod Visser, Purchasing and Central Services
Director Pam Jones, a representative from Chapel Hill Public Works, and Mayor Kevin Foy
toured the old Chapel Hill post office. The idea is to possibly use it to serve some of the long-
term justice facility needs in the southern part of the County. There is 15,000 square feet, and
much of it is unused. He suggested that staff work with Chapel Hill staff to do a preliminary
analysis on this site as an alternative to having a site on the Homestead campus. The Board
agreed.
Commissioner Carey said that he talked with Commissioner Jacobs and Laura
Blackmon earlier about instances where the County Commissioners raise an issue like this and
that the County Commissioners be cognizant that this will add more work for the staff. This
suggestion will go on the follow-up sheet. The staff needs to tell the County Commissioners if
something cannot be done in a reasonable amount of time.
Commissioner Jacobs said that he has mentioned before that there has been some
response from some of the neighboring jurisdictions about the value-added Ag center feasibility
study. Chatham County has also responded and the Economic Development Director is going
to follow up with the County Commission Chairs that have expressed interest.
Commissioner Jacobs said that he, Chair Carey, and Steve Halkiotis attended the
Cooperative Extension Breakfast this morning and the focus was on agriculture. The tentative
date for next year's Ag Summit is February 13t"
Commissioner Jacobs said that there was another meeting of the Efland-Mebane Work
Group Follow-up Committee. There was a lot of discussion about alternatives to help protect
people who live in the Buckhorn community that want to remain in residential zoning without
being taxed as an economic development district. The proposal will be brought forward to the
Board and the community.
Commissioner Jacobs said that the Carolina North Work Group met again, and there
was some progress made in talking about preserving open space at Carolina North. He said
that he is continuing to advocate for schools and making sure that the University pays the full
cost of service for its impact on schools.
Commissioner Gordon said that she attended the Orange Unified Transportation Board
meeting, the Recreation and Parks Advisory Commission meeting, and a joint transportation
meeting. She reported on the joint transportation meeting. The two groups - DCHC-MPO and
CAMPO - met on November 29t", along with representatives from TTA, Triangle J COG, and
others. The main topic was regional transportation planning for the Triangle and regional transit
planning.
Commissioner Gordon made reference to the justice facilities and said that it is very
important to get staff input regarding the needs.
Commissioner Gordan thanked the voters far re-electing her for another term. She also
thanked Rod Visser for his service as Assistant County Manager and as Interim County
Manager. She welcomed Laura Blackmon as the new County Manager . She also thanked her
husband, Alan Biermann, for supporting her during her campaign for re-election.
Chair Carey congratulated the three Commissioners, thanked Rad Visser, and
welcomed Laura Blackmon.
Chair Carey said that the County Commissioners' commitment to the Library Services
Task Force report continues to be strong. He suggested updating the report, now that the new
central library has been approved for construction.
Commissioner Gordon said that this would be a good idea if it does not take too long to
get the update, and if it could be incorporated into the budget process.
Commissioner Jacobs said that he does not think this would take long, because there
are only a few outstanding issues from the original report.
The Clerk will notify the members of the task force that the County Commissioners want
them to reconvene and update the report.
Commissioner Nelson said that he was on the first Library Services Task Force and he
would be interested in serving on this reconvened group. The Board agreed by consensus.
Chair Carey agreed with Commissioner Foushee about the scheduling of Board
comments in the agenda. He would like for the County Commissioners to think about, between
now and the retreat, what purpose the Board intends for these comments to serve. This will
help decide where to put the Board comments. Commissioner Gordon would like to make other
suggestions relating to the agenda.
Chair Carey said that Orange County was awarded the Employer of the Year by the
Orange Disabilities Awareness Council.
Chair Carey said that the County Commissioners passed a resolution recently in
recognition of Rev. Manley's 60t" anniversary as Pastor of First Baptist Church in Chapel Hill
and his 60 years of community service. He cannot attend the event honoring Rev. Manley and
he offered his two extra tickets for the event, which is December 9t" at 6:00 p.m. at The Friday
Center.
4. County Manager's Report
County Manager Laura Blackman made reference to the compressed natural gas facility
and said that it should be online this Wednesday.
She said that she met with staff, Commissioner Jacobs, and members of the Employee
Relations Consortium to discuss long and short-term implications of employee parking in the
downtown area with all of the construction.
She said that she has been working with staff on the tradition of the Manager's Memo,
and there should be one this week. Some of the issues include a proposal for some changes to
the Northern Park site plan. The project is on schedule, but there have been some changes
with refinement of the stream buffer.
6. Items for Decision--Consent Agenda
A motion was made by Commissioner Jacobs, seconded by Commissioner Foushee to
approve those items on the consent agenda as stated below:
a. Minutes
The Board approved the minutes for October 24, 2006, November 2, 2006 and November 9,
2006 as submitted by the Clerk to the Board.
b. Appointments -None
c. Property Tax Refunds
The Board adopted a refund resolution, which is incorporated by reference, related to three
requests for property tax refund in accordance with N.C. General Statues 105-381.
d. Property Value Changes
The Board adapted a resolution, which is incorporated by reference, approving value changes
made in property values after the 2006 Board of Equalization and Review has adjourned.
e. Applications for Property Tax Exemption
The Board approved seven untimely applications for exemptionlexclusion from ad valorem
taxation from the 2006 tax year.
f. Resolution Adjusting the Starting Salaries of the Sheriff and Register of Deeds
Positions
The Board adopted a resolution, which is incorporated by reference, adjusting the starting
salaries of the Sheriff and Register of Deeds positions, effective December 4, 2006.
g_ Service Coordination Renewal Agreement with Manley Estates and the Department on
Aging
The Board authorized the Chair to sign the Agreement to provide service coordination for the
residents of the First Baptist and Manley Estates senior housing complex in Chapel Hill.
h. Amend 2005 COPS Interoperable Communications Grant Contract With the City of
Durham
The Board amended the grant contract with the City of Durham for the 2005 US Department of
Justice COPS Interoperable Communications grant, as approved by the Board on March 2,
2006, pending final review by staff and the County Attorney and authorized the Manager to sign.
i. Application for Emergency Management Performance Grant (EMPG1
The Board received a grant from the State Emergency Management Agency to help support the
County emergency program and authorized the Interim Emergency Management Director to
sign.
L Chance in BOCC Regular Meeting Schedule for 2007
This item was removed and placed at the end of the consent agenda far separate consideration.
k. Examination of Bonds
The Board maintained the bands at their present levels.
I. Amendment to Interlocal Agreement for OperatinglSharing Cost for the Fairview
Community Policing Center
The Board approved the amendment revising the Interlocal Agreement for Operating/Sharing
Cost for the Fairview Community Policing Center and authorized the Chair to sign pending final
review by staff and the County Attorney.
m. Process and Facilitation Consultant Contract for Comprehensive Plan
This item was removed and placed at the end of the consent agenda far separate consideration.
n. Consultant Contract -Education Facilities Impact Fees
The Board directed staff to negotiate a final contract with Tischler and Associates to perform the
outlined scope of work including the consultant timeline for an amount not to exceed $60,000;
and to authorize the Manager to sign the resulting contract.
VOTE ON CONSENT AGENDA: UNANIMOUS
ITEMS REMOVED FROM CONSENT AGENDA:
L Change in BOCC Regular Meeting Schedule for 2007
The Board considered making one change in the County Commissioners' regular
meeting calendar for the year 2007.
Chair Carey asked about the meeting on January 16t". Commissioner Jacobs answered
that this is not the Board of County Commissioners' meeting. The Planning Board will be the
host, and it will be the kickoff for the facilitated comprehensive plan coordination.
Chair Carey asked if the Board would be making decisions at this meeting and it was
answered no.
A motion was made by Chair Carey, seconded by Commissioner Nelson to amend its
regular meeting calendar for 2007 by adding a meeting on Tuesday, January 16, 2007 at
Southern Human Services Center from 7:00 p.m. - 9:00 p.m.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
m. Process and Facilitation Consultant Contract for Comprehensive Plan
The Board considered reviewing the proposal from the Orange County Dispute
Settlement Center (DSC) for the provision of process and facilitation services related to the
Comprehensive Plan update and authorizing staff to prepare a contract with the Dispute
Settlement Center that incorporates the scope of work outlined under the "Cost and Contracting"
section of the proposal and authorizing the Chair to sign.
Commissioner Gordon asked haw it was contemplated that the 1981 plan was to be
used. Comprehensive Planning Supervisor Tom Altieri said that the Planning Board felt that this
would be a good starting point in the update process to look at the 1981 plan, particularly the
goals and objectives, to make some determination on what areas in which the County has been
successful in implementing and to identify some areas of focus in the new plan. He said that
the Planning Board further requests that the Board of County Commissioners would be the
Board that reviews the 1981 plan with the Planning staff's assistance and to prepare the
evaluation. He said that the goals and objectives in the 1981 plan are very general. He does
not anticipate the evaluation to take a long time.
Commissioner Gordon made reference to the two consultants and the synthesizer and
asked if it is the thought of the Planning Board that there is not enough in-house staff to
synthesize this plan. Tom Altieri said that the Planning Board will be reviewing the initial ideas
for the synthesizing consultant at the meeting on Wednesday, December 6t"
Commissioner Gordon made reference to page 6 and said that it would be a good idea
to explicitly put in that the coordinator is in charge of the meeting summary. This is item 3.
Commissioner Jacobs made reference to the comprehensive planning update timetable
and said that it has the approval of the legal ad for the public hearing in July 2007. The Board
of County Commissioners does not meet in July. He suggested moving this to June.
A motion was made by Commissioner Jacobs, seconded by Commissioner Foushee to
approve the proposal from the Orange County Dispute Settlement Center (DSC) for the
provision of process and facilitation services related to the Comprehensive Plan update and
authorize staff to prepare a contract with the Dispute Settlement Center that incorporates the
scope of work outlined under the "Cost and Contracting" section of the proposal and authorize
the Chair to sign.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
6. Resolutions or Proclamations
a. Proclamation Acknowledging Human Rights Week, Human Rights Dav, and the
Bill of Rights Dav
The Board considered officially recognizing Human Rights Week, Human Rights Day,
and the Bill of Rights Day in Orange County during the month of December, and authorizing the
Chair to sign the proclamation.
Cutler Andrews, a member of the Orange County Human Relations Commission, said
that he is here on behalf of the HRC to accept this proclamation. He listed the upcoming events
in the area -International Human Rights Award Dinner at N. C. State University Club on
December 5t"; Vigils against torture flags on December 9t" and December 23~d in Raleigh
(carpools available in Chapel Hill by calling 942-2535); and Bill of Rights Day celebration on
December 15t" at the Carrbora Century Center Fountain from 12:00-1:00 p.m.
He also welcomed Laura Blackmon and Commissioner Nelson to Orange County on
behalf of the HRC. He read the proclamation.
A motion was made by Commissioner Jacobs, seconded by Commissioner Nelson to
approve recognizing Human Rights Week, Human Rights Day, and the Bill of Rights Day in
Orange County during the month of December, and authorize the Chair to sign the
proclamation.
PROCLAMATION
WHEREAS, on December 10, 1948, the member States of the United Nations signed
the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and countries of different
political, economic and social systems agreed an the fundamental rights
that all people share solely on the basis of their common humanity; and
WHEREAS, Human Rights Day and Human Rights Week were adopted by the United
Nations in connection with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights;
and
WHEREAS, the Bill of Rights Day was first declared in 1941 by President Franklin
Delano Roosevelt to commemorate the 1791 Ratification of the Bill of
Rights; and
WHEREAS, the Bill of Rights guarantees, among other basic liberties, freedom of
speech and of the press as well as freedom of religion and association;
and
WHEREAS, the Bill of Rights states that no person shall be deprived of life, liberty or
property without due process of law and establishes fundamental rules of
fairness in judicial proceedings, including the right to trial by jury; and
WHEREAS, the primary responsibility to promote respect for these rights and freedoms
lies with each individual in Orange County, and each of us can play a
major role in enhancing human rights; and
WHEREAS, the residents of Orange County support Human Rights and recognize that
the "inherent dignity and the equal and inalienable rights of all members
of the human family are the foundation of freedom, justice and peace;"
NOW, THEREFORE, We, The Board of County Commissioners of Orange County,
North Carolina, do hereby proclaim December 10 -16, 2006 to be HUMAN RIGHTS WEEK
and December 10, 2006 as HUMAN RIGHTS DAY and December 15, 2006 as BILL of
RIGHTS DAY in Orange County and challenge our residents to study and promote the
ideas contained in these documents to the end that freedom, justice, and equality shall
not perish but will flourish and be made available to all.
THIS THE 4th DAY OF DECEMBER, 2006.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
7. Special Presentations
a. Presentation of the Orange County Women's Agenda for 2006-2007
The Board considered receiving the results and prioritizing the issues of the Orange
County Women's Agenda Assembly. Commissioner Foushee and Commissioner Gordon
attended this event.
Cutler Andrews is the Chair of the Advocacy Subcommittee of the Commission for
Women. He gave the results of Orange County Women's Agenda Assembly, which took place
on October 12th at the Southern Human Services Center. The priority issues that were
identified, in descending order, were economic self-sufficiency, access to health care,
education, child care, violence against women, and civic participation and equality. The
Commission will join other counties at the General Assembly in February 2007 to present this
agenda to the State legislators. He asked the County Commissioners to keep the Orange
County Women's Agenda in mind as policy is formulated throughout the year. He congratulated
the County for having its first female County Manager.
Commissioner Gordon commended the Commission for Women on its work and also
Commissioner Foushee as the liaison. She said that, while all of the priorities are important,
she was glad to see economic self-efficiency at the top of their list.
Commissioner Jacobs commended this group also. He made reference to page six,
which addresses older citizens, healthcare, and improving wages and benefits for aides in long-
term care facilities. He said that the childcare services community is looking for the exact same
kind of support and training for its employees. It struck him that there is no leadership outside
of Orange County in this area. He suggested thinking about, with the social safety net, how the
County can start to address these service areas and get better training and wages. He also
made reference to page 13, where it addresses equal public representation, and said that he is
becoming more convinced that they need to open up the political process and have non-
partisan County Commissioner elections. He also thinks that the Board should consider looking
at trying to help with public financing of County Commissioner election races. It is starting to
become expensive.
Commissioner Foushee said that there is a collaborative effort between HRC and the
Commission far Women and the number of student volunteers impressed her.
Chair Carey said that he was unable to attend this event and he commended all for their
work. He said that all of the action items were focused at the State level and he would like to
lend some local action to this as well.
Commissioner Foushee said that, among the Commission, it is felt that the County is
going over and beyond.
Human Rights and Relations Director Milan Pham said that the next step after they
present to the legislatures is to return to the local governments to see how they are faring on the
Women's Agenda.
A motion was made by Commissioner Gordon, seconded by Commissioner Foushee to
accept the Orange County Women's Agenda.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
8. Public Hearings-NONE
9. Items for Decision--Regular Agenda
a. Bennett-Andrews Preliminary Plan
The Board considered the Preliminary Plan and possible revisions for the Bennett-
AndrewsSubdivision.
Planning Director Craig Benedict said that this item was an the Board of County
Commissioners' agenda on October 3rd. It was referred back to the Planning Board with same
additional information. This subdivision is an $5-acre property and is made up of two lots of
record. When the subdivision originally came to staff at the end of last year, it was in one piece
as two lots of record, and the owners were interested in having a new conservation cluster and
leaving the existing lot on one tract and leaving the existing house and tract on the other lot of
record. In the spring, the applicant decided to focus on the conservation cluster portion, which
was 18 acres of the 85. He said that he and the County Attorney looked at this and found out
that in order to maintain the 1989 zoning density requirements for areas within the University
Lake Critical Area Watershed, that lots of record would have to be considered in total. There
are five two-acre lots allowed as an initial density calculation, and then five acres thereafter.
There is now an 18-lot conservation cluster, which is a subdivision with 33% open space. It is
also nestled into two estate lots, which are 14 acres and 5-6 acres.
Staff is suggesting, and DOT agrees that a right turn deceleration lane into the project
would be beneficial and allow better traffic flaw an Jones Ferry Road. Another suggestion from
the Town of Carrboro, since this is in the courtesy review area that the road be stubbed out to
the north to connect with Sesame Road. Staff has analyzed this and does not recommend
stubbing this out to the north because of the Neville Creek floodplain and environmental areas
to the north. This parcel was subject to the Adequate Public Facilities Ordinance and there is
enough capacity with the elementary and middle levels and the site was given a certificate of
adequate public schools.
The Planning Board unanimously approved this on November 15t, and the minutes of the
meeting are attached.
A motion was made by Commissioner Gordan, seconded by Commissioner Jacobs to
approve the Preliminary Plan with the following revisions to the Resolution of Approval:
Replace Resolution Item F.11 with the fallowing: "The awnerlapplicant shall install water
withdrawal signage for the withdrawal of water for fire suppression from Moore Pond (a private
pond} off of Deerfield Trail. signage shall be acceptable to, and approved in writing by, the
Carrboro Fire Department and the Orange County Fire Marshal.
Replace Resolution Item F.13 with the fallowing: "The maximum impervious surface
coverage that may be allocated to the 18 individual conservation cluster subdivision lots shall be
as noted in the Impervious Data {but not the "Notes"} on Sheet C-1 of the Bennett-Andrews
Preliminary Plan. This figure is exclusive of the Orchard Lane right-of-way. The maximum
impervious surface coverage on the Tanaka estate lot is 1.08 acres. The maximum impervious
surface an the Creek estate lot is .33 acres. The maximum impervious surface coverage for
each lot, including the two estate lots, shall be shown on the Final Plan."
Add Resolution Item F.15 as follows: "The Final Plan may be drawn on one or more
plats, however all final plats must be recorded contemporaneously with one another."
Commissioner Jacobs said that he appreciates the analysis of the cumulative traffic
impacts.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
b. Justice Facilities Expansion Project Review and Approval
The Board considered receiving the final review and comment on the Justice Facilities
Project, including the River Park and the Farmer's Market, prior to the solicitation of bids.
Purchasing and Central Services Director Pam Janes said that this is the final project
review in the approval of the expansion project. The Historic District Commission of
Hillsborough and the Board of Adjustment for the Town of Hillsborough have both approved this.
There are five conditions of approval from the Board of Adjustment. She noted a correction in
the abstract -instead of the bids being taken January 23rd, it will be February 8t"
David Taylor from Corley Redfoot and Zack made a PowerPoint presentation of layouts.
He said that the architect has met with about 20 different agencies or groups on this project,
and has received approval from the agencies in Hillsborough as stated above and other groups
have given input. He said that the basic conceptual plan has remained intact. The project
includes a 38,000-square foot addition on three stories to the existing new Orange County
courthouse. The project also includes a public market house, a set of remote toilets (on a part
of the existing Sheriff's Department building), a passive park with trails, the riverwalk, etc. One
of the five conditions from the Board of Adjustment was to make sure that the eastern end of the
trail was coordinated with the Classical American Homes Preservation Trust and the work that
will be done beyond the site. The other conditions include making the remote toilet accessible,
approval of the storm water plans by the Town's consulting engineers, a written plan for the
remote parking facility, and the building elevations dated October 18, 2006 are the final version.
The public market house is a 24-stall laminated pavilion. The Board has already pre-
purchased the laminated structure for this project. It will be an open structure with two stalls per
bay and adouble-loaded corridor down the middle. He went through some of the minor
changes that have been made by various agencies, primarily the Historic District Commission.
The dormers became more regular, the same types of setbacks have been retained from the
original conceptual plan, there will be a public pavilion and public information kiosk on Margaret
Lane, the dormers on the Sheriff's Office have become lined up with the windows below, and
the courtyard side has retained a curving curtain wall. There is an exterior staircase that is code
related for the courthouse because the courtroom currently does not have a code accepted
second means of egress. There will be a new security checkpoint in what is now the Criminal
Clerk's area, which will be a one-stop security checkpoint for the entire complex.
The architect will be meeting with the members of Orange County Public Works and
other Town officials, Department of Insurance, and Orange County Building and Inspections to
get input. This will be put out just after the first of the year, bids will be taken on February 8t"
and hopefully construction will start around March 15-April 1. The addition will probably be the
first thing built, taking approximately 16 months. The existing courthouse will still be in use and
most of the court functions will be moved off site. Then the existing courthouse will be
renovated. The plan is to get the farmer's market up and running by June 1, 2007.
Commissioner Gordan asked about the courtroom and David Taylor said that the
courtroom is about 2,400 square feet and the gallery space is enough far 70-80 people. It was
determined that the best arrangement was to maximize the arena area of the courtroom and
provide limited seating since there were two existing courtrooms, which would hold a significant
number of people. Commissioner Gordon said that she thought they were both going to be jury
capable. David Taylor said that they worked with Judge Buckner on this issue and after
reviewing the workload, it was decided that two jury rooms were not needed.
Commissioner Jacobs said that there was discussion atone point about having the
courtroom be transformable into mare of a flexible meeting space. David Taylor said that this
can be investigated further. He said that it is difficult to move out the furniture that is in there.
Commissioner Jacobs would like to flag this issue so that the Board could make a conscious
decision to let this passibility go if it will not work.
Commissioner Jacobs said that he read about the archaeological survey, but he has not
seen anything. Pam Jones said that some remarkable items have been found, but there is not a
report yet on this. This has been moved to a phase I I assessment. This will not affect the
construction.
Commissioner Jacobs asked about the decision to remove paver poles on Margaret
lane and the left-turn stacking. Pam Jones said that Duke Power can remove anything at a very
high price. It is not in the project budget at this paint. Commissioner Jacobs asked the staff to
get a specific price on this.
David Taylor said that apull-off area will be created for mass transit that will take out
some of the parallel parking spaces. The hope is to get people to stop pulling off right in front of
the courthouse.
Pam Jones said that there is also information on narrowing the sidewalks and increasing
the lane sa that it could be stacked. The civil engineer has this information.
Commissioner Jacobs said that the Public Market House was supposed to be ready by
May 1St. Pam Jones said yes and David Taylor said that they would shoot for May 15c
Commissioner Jacobs said that there was also discussion about having wireless
capability at the bus shelter and David Taylor said that this could be done as an alternate. It
cannot be done with the project budget. Pam Jones said that the County staff could do this
later.
Commissioner Jacobs said that he does not think that this will be expensive, and he
thinks that people who are using the bus and are waiting will be encouraged to use the bus if
they can continue to work.
Commissioner Jacobs asked if the thought was having the remote restrooms be unisex
and David Taylor said that code will probably say that one has to be male and one has to be
female.
Commissioner Gordon made reference to the larger of the two courtrooms and the
flexibility of using this as a meeting space. She supported Commissioner Jacobs' comments
about having this flexibility. She also noted that when this area is being constructed, there will a
lot of earth moving because of the utilization of geothermal wells; and they need to make sure
the public is aware of this because it might be shocking otherwise.
David Taylor pointed out that one of the main sustainable issues of the building is that
there will be a geothermal HVAC system, which will serve the new addition and will back feed
everything at the existing courthouse, with the exception of the Battle Courtroom, which is fed
by the rooftop units. In the park area, there will be a series of 300-foot wells for this system.
Commissioner Jacobs said that there should be some public information component
about the geothermal wells being drilled. He suggested having same kind of illustration placed
at the drilling site and on the website so that people know what is going on.
A motion was made by Commissioner Foushee, seconded by Commissioner Nelson to
approve the design of the Justice Facilities Expansion Project elements as presented.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
c. Ethics and Conduct for County Public Servant Policy
The Board considered adopting an Orange County policy establishing ethics and
conduct for County public servants.
Geof Gledhill said that the Board has talked about an ethics and conduct policy in the
past. In March of this year, he reported back to the Board and a summary of the report is
attached. He has discovered that many communities have ethics policies and that the policies
are not strong in specifics. The State has been involved in the last couple of years in trying to
develop a comprehensive ethics policy for State government employees and elected officials.
This gained momentum in this last session of the General Assembly because of some of the
ethical problems the assembly encountered. He was surprised that the ethics policy was
adopted by the General Assembly. The policy is comprehensive and raises the bar on public
recording of the kinds of activities that public servants are involved with. He said that it seemed
that the Board was looking for specificity and comprehensiveness, and he tried to provide
something of this nature. He said that there is no law for counties to adopt an ethics policy, but
it can be enforceable by the Board of County Commissioners with respect to advisory boards.
With respect to County employees, there may be issues associated with whether or not this
policy will apply to people who are already employed. The issues will have to be addressed on
a case-by-case basis.
Commissioner Nelson commended Geof Gledhill for this thorough policy and his
extraordinary effort and he also commended Representative Jae Hackney for his work in the
General Assembly on this issue.
Commissioner Jacobs said that when he was in San Francisco, there was a story about
a Planning Director who had accepted a membership in a country club that was worth $100,000
from a group of people that wanted to influence the planning policy. He asked if this policy
would cover something like that because the person was previously employed and was not a
new employee. Geof Gledhill said that Orange County has a personnel ordinance that creates
a properly right for employees. Some of the policies may have to be integrated into the
personnel ordinance.
Commissioner Jacobs suggested simplifying this policy for the boards and commissions.
Commissioner Gordon made reference to the boards and commissions and asked for a
list of ones that are created by State statutes and ones that would come under this policy.
Commissioner Gordon said that she would appreciate a good form for these ethics
compliance reports and Geof Gledhill said that he, Laura Blackmon, and the Clerk will work on
this.
Chair Carey said that this policy applies to all elected and appointed officials and he
asked if it includes the Sheriff and Register of Deeds. Geof Gledhill said nat unless they want to
be included because they are constitutional officers. Chair Carey would like to clarify this. Geof
Gledhill suggested having a conversation with the Sheriff and the Register of Deeds.
Chair Carey asked about the legislative participation and if a Board member wants to
abstain from a vote, he or she has to provide a written request. He would like this to be a verbal
abstaining rather than having it in written form. Geof Gledhill said that his purpose for a written
requirement is for a record of it. Chair Carey said that the minutes would be a record.
Commissioner Gordon questioned item `k' on page 8, where liabilities of the immediate
family would have to be listed. It was answered that this would not include emancipated
children. She asked haw often this would be updated and Geof Gledhill said that this has an
annual reporting requirement.
Commissioner Gordon said that overall this ethics policy is a good thing.
Chair Carey made reference to page 6 and the definition of a public servant, where it
refers to members of the Board of Commissioners or an elected or appointed member of the
County Board of Commissioners before taking office. He asked if Commissioner Nelson was
considered a public servant from the time he was elected on November 7t". Geof Gledhill said
that he would be considered a public servant when participating in official action.
Commissioner Gordon suggested that the Board take another look at this and submit
comments to the Chair and/or the Manager and bring this back on a consent agenda.
Commissioner Jacobs and Commissioner Foushee agreed.
Chair Carey agreed and suggested making the inquiry to the Sheriff and Register of
Deeds. He said that he would make the inquiry.
Chair Carey said to direct comments to the Attorney and copy the Chair.
The Board agreed to defer this item.
1Q. Reports-NONE
11. Closed Session-NONE
12. Adjournment
A motion was made by Commissioner Jacobs, seconded by Commissioner Gordon to
adjourn the meeting at 10:14 p.m.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
Moses Carey, Jr., Chair
Donna S. Baker
Clerk to the Board