HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda - 08-30-2011 - 1cORANGE COUNTY
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
ACTION AGENDA ITEM ABSTRACT
Meeting Date: August 3D, 2D11
Action Agenda
Item No. ~...- c.
SUBJECT: Update on Upper Neuse River Basin Association Activities
DEPARTMENT: Environment, Agriculture,
Parks and Recreation
(DEAPR)
PUBLIC HEARING: (Y/N) No
ATTACHMENT(S):
INFORMATION CONTACT:
Commissioner Pam Hemminger, Chair of
UNRBA, 245-2130
David Stancil, 245=2510
Thomas Davis, 245-2513
PURPOSE: To inform the Board of recent and possible upcoming Upper Neuse River Basin
Association (UNRBA) activities.
BACKGROUND: The State of North Carolina's Falls Lake Nutrient Management Strategy
(Falls Lake Rules) became effective in January 2011. These rules require massive reductions
in the amounts of nitrogen and phosphorus entering Falls Lake from agriculture, wastewater
treatment plants, State and Federal facilities, and existing and future development activities.
The fiscal analysis prepared by the NC Division of Water Quality (DWQ) estimated the cost of
compliance with these rules to be $1.5 billion in 2010 dollars, with the majority of the expense
anticipated to be borne by local governments in the upper Falls Lake watershed, mainly to
comply with the regulations involving wastewater treatment plants and existing development
(urban areas). While the regulations require the implementation of several measures in the
next ten years, significant action will be needed during Stage II of the nutrient reduction process
(2021-2041) to meet the overall reduction goals established in the rules.
As a result, in July 2011 the Upper Neuse River Basin Association (UNRBA) began the process
of hiring a consultant "for the development of methods by which the regulatory framework
associated with the recently adopted Falls Lake Nutrient Management Rules can be evaluated."
According to the UNRBA's request for proposals, "The Falls Rules are costly and require
actions on the part of UNRBA member governments and other regulated parties that are
unprecedented. In light of the potential financial impact of these rules and importance of the
resource, the UNRBA wishes to secure assistance in evaluating the technical bases and
regulatory framework for the Falls Rules, particularly the more costly Stage II."
2
The UNRBA expects to select a consultant in September 2011 to begin working on this project.
As stated in- the July Request for Proposals, "This contract is anticipated to be-the first of
several that the UNRBA expects to execute regarding Falls Lake and the Falls Lake
watershed." The tasks that the UNRBA has identified for the initial phase of work are as
follows:
1. Develop Framework for a Re-examination of Stage II of the Falls Nutrient Strategy
2. Review Existing Data and Reports to Summarize Knowledge of Falls Lake and the Falls
Lake Watershed
3. Review Methods for Delivered and Jurisdictional Nutrient Loads
4. Recommendations for Future Monitoring and- Modeling
Of particular interest, it is anticipated that Task 3 (listed above) will result in the determination of
nutrient loading for each of the jurisdictions in the Falls Lake watershed.
Given the anticipated cost for some parties to comply with the Falls Lake Rules, and the
potential reduction in costs for these parties if the Rules are revised or changed, it is expected
that considerable interest exists in pursuing whatever studies are needed to attain the goal of
reducing the nutrient reductions required by the Falls Lake Rules. It is conceivable that the
UNRBA could continue to lead- studies of Falls Lake and the surrounding watershed for the next
ten years in an effort to change (perhaps having the impact of weakening) Stage II of the
nutrient regulations. It should be pointed out that-the UNRBA agrees that the preservation of
Falls L-ake as a water supply is of paramount importance.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: None at the current time; however, activities undertaken by the UNRBA
over the next-ten years or so could require additional increases in the annual contributions by
the County. Orange County as a part of the FY 2011-2012 budget increased its funding for this
purpose to $26,100. This represents a doubling of the UNRBA dues from the previous year in
anticipation of hiring a consultant to perform the tasks listed above. It is probable that future
funding of the UNRBA will continue at this new, higher amount for some time as a result of the
increased activities undertaken by the organization.
RECOMMENDATION(S): The Manager recommends that the Board consider and discuss the
information presented concerning possible UNRBA actions related to Falls Lake.