HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 19961001APPROVED 1212196
MINUTES
ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
REGULAR MEETING
OCTOBER 1, 1996
The Orange County Board of Commissioners met in regular session on October 1, 1996 at 7:30
p.m. in the courtroom of the Old County Courthouse in Hillsborough, North Carolina.
COUNTY COMMISSIONERS PRESENT: Chair Moses Carey, Jr., and Commissioners William
L. Crowther, Alice M. Gordon, Stephen H. Halkiotis and Don Willhoit.
COUNTY ATTORNEY PRESENT: Geoffrey Gledhill
COUNTY STAFF PRESENT: County Manager John M. Link, Jr., Assistant County Managers
Rod Visser and Albert Kittrell and Clerk to the Board Beverly A. Blythe (All other staff members will be
identified appropriately below)
NOTE: ALL DOCUMENTS REFERRED TO IN THESE MINUTES ARE IN THE PERMANENT
AGENDA FILE IN THE CLERK'S OFFICE. ALL RECORDING TAPES OF THE
MEETING WILL BE KEPT FOR FIVE (5) YEARS.
1. ADDITIONS OR CHANGES TO THE AGENDA
The Board removed the Planning Board appointments from the Consent Agenda to consider as a
separate item. They replaced the name of Sarah Stewart with Judy White for the Orange County
statewide School Bond Committee. Item #5 and #6 were reversed.
2. AUDIENCE COMMENTS
a. Matters on the Printed Agenda
Chair Carey said that citizens who have indicated a desire to speak will be recognized at the
appropriate time.
b. Matters not on the Printed Agenda - NONE
PUBLIC CHARGE
Chair Carey dispensed with the reading of the Public Charge.
3. BOARD COMMENTS
Commissioner Halkiotis asked about the procedure for those citizens believed to have been
involved with price gouging in the County. Geoffrey Gledhill explained that the information will go to the
Attorney General's office and then to the local District Attorney's office. Two statutes are involved -- one
dealing with trade practices and one dealing with obtaining property by false pretenses. Commissioner
Halkiotis commended FEMA for their help during this cleanup period after the hurricane.
In answer to a question about space for supplies from the Red Cross, Purchasing Director Pam
Jones indicated that the County has arranged to provide a tractor trailer to store these items. It will be
housed at the Public Works facility off of 86 North.
Commissioner Halkiotis made reference to the concern expressed by Dawn Minton at the last
meeting and said that he met with her to discuss the issues involved with her concern. He said that the
problem is a small culvert pipe that needs to be enlarged. He asked that staff work with DOT to get this
work accomplished.
Commissioner Willhoit made reference to an article in the newspaper about a change in animal tag
procedures and expressed a concern that this is not a move that is customer oriented. The primary goal
of the licensing program is to be sure that all animals have a rabies tag and the owner can be identified
by tracing the number on the rabies tag. He asked that the Health Department rethink this change.
John Link indicated that he has talked with Dan Reimer and his understanding is that the County
will continue to require the rabies tag which can be traced back to the owner. What is not being required
is the County ID tag. Citizens are encouraged to buy an identification tag. In the ordinance amendment
last year, the requirement for an identification tag was eliminated. This will save the County six or seven
thousand dollars a year.
Chair Carey noted he wrote a letter to Tommy Dyer at DOT requesting additional help in removing
debris from the hurricane, especially in areas outside of the municipalities.
4. COUNTY MANAGER'S REPORT
John Link said that staff is investigating funding resources for removing debris blocking streams in
the County. He will report back on this item. FEMA and the SBA will continue to work out of the Cedar
Falls Courtyard in Chapel Hill. Ken Chavious is working on reimbursements for mileage and overtime
caused by the hurricane.
5. RESOLUTIONS/PROCLAMATIONS
a. Efland Sewer Force Main Tap Resolution
County Engineer Paul Thames spoke about the engineering requirements of the resolution
and Geoffrey Gledhill spoke to the scope of the intent of the resolution. Paul Thames outlined the five
(5) points of contention with which Ben Lloyd disagrees and answered various questions from the County
Commissioners.
Ben Lloyd said that his two concerns involve (1) the requirement of a manhole and (2)
encasement of the pipe.
Commissioner Halkiotis said that something needs to be done for all the citizens in the Efland
area where there are septic tank problems.
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Willhoit to
approve the resolution as presented in the agenda and stated below which will permit the connection of
sewer service for Lloyd's Car Wash, located at the southeastern corner of the intersection of US Hwy 70
and Efland-Cedar Grove Road in the community of Efland, by tapping into the portion of the primary
Efland sewer force main lying near that intersection:
RESOLUTION PROVIDING PERMISSION FOR
SEWER SERVICE FOR LLOYD'S CAR WASH IN EFLAND
BY TAPPING THE FORCE MAIN OF THE ORANGE COUNTY
EFLAND SEWER SYSTEM
WHEREAS, A. B. Lloyd, Jr. has represented to Orange County that he is now and for more than
twenty years has been the sole owner and operator of a self-service car wash in Efland located on the
southeast corner of US Hwy 70 and Efland-Cedar Grove Road; and
WHEREAS, it has been determined and ruled by the North Carolina Division of Water Quality
(formerly the Division of Environmental Management) and the North Carolina Environmental
Management Commission that said car wash does not meet state environmental statues regulating the
discharge of waste water and is thus improperly discharging untreated waste wash water to the land
surface which drains into McGowan Creek and thence the Eno River, each classified as a WS-II level,
high quality water supply resource within a stringently regulated and protected watershed; and
WHEREAS, the EMC has ordered that A.B. Lloyd, Jr. terminate the surface discharge of waste
wash water from the car wash: and
WHEREAS, it has been determined by environmental officials that no on-site waste water
treatment alternative exists: and
WHEREAS, Orange County owns and operates the Efland Sewer System; and
WHEREAS, the only two options available for mitigating the discharge are to close the car wash or
to discharge the waste into the Efland Sewer System; and
WHEREAS, a portion of the Efland Sewer System force main lies along the north side of US Hwy
70 and directly across from the Lloyd Car Wash; and
WHEREAS, it is Orange County's policy and practice to prohibit force main taps or connections into
sewer systems which it owns or in which it participates, including the Efland Sewer System, particularly
where the sewer system is not designed for force main taps or connections, because of the risk to the
environment and the risk to the proper functioning of the utility system associated with such taps or
connections; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Commissioners has determined that this policy and practice should allow
for a force main tap or connection when all of the following are present:
1. The land and the facility to be served are located in an Urban or Transition area as
identified in the Land Use Element of the Orange County Comprehensive Plan; and
2. The connection to the force main will, in all other respects, comply with the Orange
County Water and Sewer Policy and will comply with federal, State and Orange County policies, laws,
regulations and rules applicable to the sewer system to which the force main connection will be made;
and
3. The connection will correct a violation of a federal, State or local government policy, law,
regulation or rule regulating the discharge of waste water into the waters of the State which violation is
the result of a federal, State or local policy, law, regulation or rule requirement which was not a
requirement at the time the waste water system serving the land and the facility was constructed; and
4. The force main tap or connection will be temporary in that there is a gravity sewer
alternative to the force main or connection planned and the probability is that the gravity sewer
alternative will be constructed within five (5) years of the force main tap or connection AND the owner of
the land and facility, for the owner, the owners heirs and assigns, agrees to pay all fees and costs for
and make, in compliance with all federal, State and local policies, laws, regulations and rules in effect at
the time of the connection to the gravity sewer line alternative, a sewer tap or connection to the gravity
sewer alternative within sixty (60) days after it is available adjacent to the land where the force main tap
or connection has been made; and
WHEREAS, the force main tap or connection to Lloyd's Car Wash can meet, with the agreement of
the owner of Lloyd's Car Wash and the owner of the land upon which it is located, all four of the
conditions specified above.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF
ORANGE COUNTY THAT:
1. The owner of Lloyd's Car Wash and the owner of the land upon which it is located may
construct a temporary, pressurized sewer service lateral and tap that lateral into the portion of the Efland
Sewer System force main lying directly across US Hwy 70 from the car wash; and
2. The owner of Lloyd's Car Wash and the owner of the land upon which it is located shall
employ the services of a professional engineer licensed by the State of North Carolina and qualified by
virtue of education and experience to practice in the field of sanitary engineering to design a pressurized
sewer service lateral system to serve Lloyd's Car Wash; and
3. The pressurized sewer service lateral system shall include a high-head low flow grinder
pump system including a holding/pump tank and discharge flow metering equipment; small diameter
valves, fittings and force main or pressure sewer service lateral extended under US Hwy 70 with
encasement piping under US Hwy 70; and a waterproof vault or manhole containing the force main tap
and the necessary shut-off and backflow preventing value assemblies; and
4. In addition to obtaining system design approval from the Orange County Engineer, the
owner of Lloyd's Car Wash and the owner of the land upon which it is located and his/her or their
engineer shall be responsible for complying with all necessary permitting and system design approval
procedures of the Division of Water Quality, the North Carolina Department of Transportation and
Orange County and shall submit evidence of those approvals to the County Engineer; and
5. The owner of Lloyd's Car Wash and the owner of the land upon which it is located shall
properly execute the SEWER EASEMENT DECLARATION attached to this resolution as "Exhibit A."
VOTE: AYES, 3; NOS (Commissioners Carey and Gordon)
For the record, Commissioner Gordon voted against this resolution because she felt it is not
good public policy.
6. SPECIAL PRESENTATIONS
a. Honorary Recognition for Officer Bruce w. Collins
This resolution was presented to and received by the family of Bruce W. Collins.
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Halkiotis to approve the
resolution for Flight Officer Bruce W. Collins as stated below:
HONORARY RECOGNITION
FOR
FLIGHT OFFICER BRUCE W. COLLINS
WHEREAS, Bruce W. Collins was born on April 2, 1920 in Nash County to Mr. and Mrs. Joel S. Collins of
Hillsboro, North Carolina, and
WHEREAS, Bruce W. Collins attended Orange County Schools and graduated from Chapel Hill High in the
class of 1941. and
WHEREAS, Bruce W. Collins decided at the young age of 21 to volunteer for the Army and upon hearing about
Pearl Harbor was determined to join the Army Air Corp, completing his first solo flight on
September 3, 1942, and
WHEREAS, Flight Officer Bruce W. Collins on February 7, 1944, as a member of the 309th Fighter Squadron,
31st Fighter Group, climbed inside the cockpit of his Spitfire and joined his squadron over the
beaches of Anzio, Italy where his group encountered over 35 enemy aircraft, being outnumbered
by 8 to 1, and
WHEREAS, after encountering enemy fire and being forced to fly through an allied anti-aircraft barrage, flight
Officer Collins disappeared with no radio contact or visual siting of his plane, and
WHEREAS, after 52 years since this incident, Bruce's family held a memorial service in remembrance of this
patriotic young man who gave his life for his country, and
WHEREAS, the survivors include four brothers and two sisters: Dr. Bobby Collins and Glen Collins of Durham
County and Vera C. Walker, Edward Collins, Jane C. Kirkland and Don Collins of Orange County
who feel that even though his body was never found, his person and spirit shall always remain with
us.
NOW, THEREFORE, we the Orange County Board of Commissioners do hereby join in this memorial to Flight
Officer Bruce W. Collins, a young man who made the ultimate sacrifice for doing what he loved the
most, and ask that all citizens in Orange County remember Bruce for his dedication to his country
and his warm and kind nature, and
FURTHER, LET IT BE RESOLVED that this honorary recognition be spread upon the minute book of Orange
County so that future generations will know and remember the dedication of Flight Officer Bruce
W. Collins in the performance of his duty as an officer in the U.S. Army Airforce.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
7. PUBLIC HEARINGS
a. 1997 Revaluation - Schedule of Values
Tax Assessor John Smith made this report. No citizens signed up to speak.
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Halkiotis to
close the public hearing.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
b. Community Development Block Grant Program
Director of Housing and Community Development Tara Fikes said that the purpose of this
public hearing is to receive comments on the proposed FY 1997 Community Development Block Grant
Application for Orange County; approve a local financial contribution of $223,000 and to approve a
resolution authorizing submission of the formal application document by October 1, 1996.
Mr. Bennie Cecil made reference to the sewage problems the Efland area has experienced
for the last fourteen years. He supports this application and hopes that the grant goes through and that it
will be given priority.
Evelyn Cecil thanked Dr. Halkiotis and Moses Carey for their concern about the problems in
this area. She pledged her support to help in any way she can. She asked that the board help in any
way they can to extend the sewer line to this area which will serve many of the elderly in that community.
The sewage on top of the ground in this area is severe and a health hazard for the citizens who live in
Efland.
Ben Lloyd said that he supports this application and will assist in any way he can to get the
work accomplished.
William Efland does not have a sewage problem personally but knows that there are
problems in this area and asked that the Board of County Commissioners pursue this grant for the Efland
Community.
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Halkiotis to (1)
close the public hearing, (2) approve a financial commitment of $223,000 for the Efland Infrastructure
CDBG Project, with staff to develop recommendations during the next year on financing the County
share from either operating or capital funds, and (3) approve the resolution as stated below which
authorizes the submission of the CDBG Application by October 18, 1996 and (4) to authorize the Chair to
sign the application document on behalf of the Board upon approval by the County Attorney.
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING AN APPLICATION FOR COMMUNITY
DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT FUNDS
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners of Orange County, that
an application for Community Revitalization funds from the N.C. Department of Commerce is hereby
authorized. Grant funds will be used to provide public water/sewer to a neighborhood in the Efland
community. The amount requested is $850,000. The application will be submitted on or before October
18, 1996.
FURTHER, the Board of County Commissioners of Orange County authorizes the Chair of the Board of
County Commissioners to sign the application document upon approval by the County Attorney.
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
8. ITEMS FOR DECISION - CONSENT AGENDA
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Halkiotis to approve
the items on the Consent Agenda as stated below:
a. Appointments
The appointments for the Planning Board will be considered as a separate item.
The Board approved the following appointments:
Carrboro Board of Adjustment
Stephen J. Dear for an unexpired term ending 3/30/98
Commission for Women
Deborah VanDyken for an unexpired term ending 6/30197
Orange County Statewide School Bond Committee
B. Crowder-Gaines
Guido DeMaere
David Hunt
Judy White
b. Minutes
The Board approved the minutes for April 18 and April 25, 1996 as presented.
C. Subdivision Regulations Text Amendments - Securing Improvements
The Board closed the public hearing and approved the proposed amendments to the
Subdivision Regulations to relocate provisions regarding required improvements from Section V, "Plat
Specifications," to Section III, "Application and Approval Procedures," rewrite the section for clarity and to
add language regarding construction cost estimates and financial guarantees.
d. Subdivision Regulations Text Amendment - Lot Layout
The Board closed the public hearing and received the Planning Board recommendation.
They approved a proposed amendment to clarify Section IV-B-S-e by substituting the word "divided" for
the word "separated".
e. Subdivision Regulations Text Amendments - Clustered Subdivisions in Rural Buffer
The Board closed the public hearing and received the Planning Board recommendation.
They approved a proposed amendment to re-adopt cluster subdivision provisions and Concept Plan
application and approval procedures in the Rural Buffer.
f. PD-1-96 Carolina Friends School
The Board closed the public hearing and received the Planning Board recommendation.
They approved the administration's recommendation of the modification to the Special Use Permit for
Carolina Friends school based on the findings as stated in the agenda and subject to the following
condition added to those placed on the Special Use Permit in 1990 and 1992:
1. The entrance and driveway are to be kept free and clear of traffic and parked vehicles at
all times and clearly identified as fire lanes with reflective signs mounted on posts. The signs shall be
installed under the guidance and supervision of the Orange County Fire Marshal's office and shall meet
the provisions of Chapter 6 of the North Carolina State Building Code, Volume V, Fire Prevention, 1996
Edition.
g, Revised Time Schedule for Golf Course Standards Initiative
The Board approved a proposed revision to the Plan of Action for the Natural Resource
Preservation Goal, specifically the golf course standards initiative. This revision will allow amendments
to be presented at the February 24, 1997, public hearing.
h. County Auction, 1996 and Resolution Authorizing Disposal of Surplus Property of
Minimal Value
The Board declared as surplus, items as listed in the agenda and adopted a resolution
authorizing the Director of Purchasing and Central Services to conduct an auction of those personal
property items declared surplus or confiscated. The auction will be held Saturday, October 19, 1996 at
the Public works Department located on Highway 86, Hillsborough. The two resolutions approved by the
County Commissioners are stated below:
RESOLUTION
WHEREAS, Orange County desires to dispose of surplus, confiscated and abandoned property in
a manner prescribed by North Carolina State Law,
WHEREAS, Orange County has given its own departments and funded agencies the opportunity to
acquire this property prior to its disposal
WHEREAS, Orange County has determined that public auction would be the most equitable way to
dispose of surplus, confiscated and abandoned property and at the same time produce the most revenue
for the County.
NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT: the Orange County Board of Commissioners do
authorize the Director of Purchasing and Central Services to conduct a public auction of these surplus
and confiscated items found on the attached list on October 19, 1996, the auction to be held at 10:00
a.m. at the Orange County Public Works Department and to be conducted on an as is, highest bidder
basis. The auction will be conducted by Crawford's Auction Service.
FURTHERMORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT: The Orange County Board of Commissioners do
hereby authorize the Director of Purchasing and Central Services to sign over the title of those vehicles
being sold at auction so that ownership may pass to the buyer and to direct the clerk to the Board of
Commissioners to send notice of such authorization to the North Carolina Division of Motor Vehicles and
do hereby authorize the Director of Purchasing and Central Services to make the necessary adjustments
in inventory for items listed and items that have been stolen, salvaged, or destroyed or mistakenly placed
in inventory.
RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE DISPOSAL OF SURPLUS
PROPERTY OF MINIMAL VALUE
AUTHORITY
G.S. 160A-266 (c) authorizes city, county, and sanitary district governing boards to establish regulations
for disposing of their unit's personal property valued at less than $500 for any one item or group of items.
The statute empowers a governing board to authorize one or more of its administrative officials to
declare surplus any such personal property, to set its fair market value, and to convey title to it for the
unit. The governing board's regulations may provide for private or public sale and exchanges, with or
without published notice.
PURPOSE
It is the purpose of the regulations established by this resolution to create policies and procedures for
Orange County that will promote the timely disposal of surplus property of limited value at fair prices for
the benefit of Orange County and the protection of the taxpayers' interest in the efficient conduct of
public business.
POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
1. The Purchasing and Central Services Director may declare surplus any item or groups of items of
personal property on the recommendation of the department head having custody of such property if (1)
its value is estimated by the Purchasing and Central Services Director and the department head to be
less than $500, and (b) the Purchasing and Central Services Director finds no use in any other
department in Orange County for the property.
2. The Purchasing and Central Services Director shall attempt to find alternative use in another
Orange County department for all personal property recommended to be declared surplus by any
department head.
3. The Purchasing and Central Services Director may dispose of any personal property valued at less
than $500 in exchange for other personal property by private negotiation, or as a trade-in on the
purchase of other personal property.
4. The Purchasing and Central Services Director may dispose of, and convey title to, any surplus
personal property valued at less than $500 for any item or group of items for which no alternative use
within the Orange County offices has been found and which cannot be traded-in or exchanged in the
acquisition of other personal property. The Purchasing and Central Services director shall dispose of
such personal property in any manner designed to secure fair value for the property, with or without
published notice, in any of the following ways:
(a) at private sale,
(b) at standard fixed prices by sale through the County's Purchasing Department and in
accord with rules and regulations concerning the handling of funds as the finance
officer shall establish,
(c) by receipt of written bid quotations, or
(d) by consignment to merchants or dealers in used goods
5. The Purchasing and Central Services Director shall submit to the governing board semi-annual
reports on the disposal of personal property pursuant to these policies and procedures. The reports shall
be submitted by August 1 and February 1 of each year and shall cover the six months ending on June 30
and December 31, respectively. The reports shall show each item or group of items disposed of, the
purchaser, the value received, and the method of disposal used. The Purchasing and Central Services
Director may not personally purchase any surplus personal property covered by these rules and
regulations, nor may the Purchasing and Central Services Director approve the sale of any such
personal property to any member of his/her immediate family.
6. The Purchasing and Central Services Director may not dispose of any surplus property covered by
these rules and regulations to any Orange County employee until thirty days after submitting to the
Board of Commissioners a written report on the proposed goods, and the proposed purchase price are
set forth. The purpose of the report is to make public the proposed transactions. Approval of the Board
of Commissioners is not necessary, but the Board of Commissioners may prohibit any proposed
transaction reported to it.
i. Bid Award for 21 Personal Computers for Social Services
The Board awarded the bid for twenty-one (21) personal computers for Social Services to
P.C. Innovations of Cary, North Carolina at a delivered cost of $974.00 per computer. Other bids
received are listed below:
Computrack $ 1,099.00
Trimet Computer 1,175.00
IBM 1,317.75
Logical Choice 1,651.00
L Services of Mechanical Engineer Re: HVAC Systems in the Court Street Annex
The Board approved the professional services of Gary Merritt, PE for specifications and
construction documents necessary for the replacement of the heating and air system in the Court Street
Annex for a sum of $6,000 and authorized the Purchasing Director to execute the appropriate
paperwork.
k. Bid Award - Renovation of Heating System _ Central Recreation Building in
Hillsborough
The Board approved the contract and awarded the bid, contingent upon final review, to
Warren-Hay Mechanical Contractors, Inc. for Heating System Renovation work at the Central Recreation
Center for a sum of $38,500 and authorized the Chair to sign on behalf of the Board.
Other bids were received from Comfort Engineers for $74,929.00 and Quality Mechanical at $62,700.
1. Contract Approval - Testing Services for Southern Human Services Center
Construction Proiect
The Board approved a contract with Trigon Engineering for testing services associated with
the Southern Human Services Center construction project in an amount not-to-exceed $22,652.75 and
authorized the Purchasing Director to execute the appropriate paperwork.
m. Professional Service Contracts - UNC School of Dentistry
The Board approved and authorized the Chair to sign the renewal of the contract with the
UNC-School of Dentistry, Department of Dental Ecology, for the services of a dental resident to provide
dental services in the Health Department.
VOTE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA: UNANIMOUS
PLANNING BOARD APPOINTMENTS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA
Commissioner Gordon nominated Jay Zargoza for the Eno vacancy on the Planning Board .
Commissioner Willhoit nominated Nell Andrews for this same position.
VOTE: Jay Zargoza - received one vote (Commissioner Gordon )
Nell Andrews - received 4 votes (Commissioners Carey, Crowther, Halkiotis and Willhoit)
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Gordon to change
Renee Price from an At Large representative to the Hillsborough representative.
VOTE: AYES, 3; NOS, 2 (Commissioners Carey and Halkiotis)
NOTE: This leaves an AT LARGE position open on this Board and it will be advertised accordingly.
9. ITEMS FOR DECISION -REGULAR AGENDA
a. Zoninq Ordinance Text Amendment - Telecommunication Towers
Planner Mary Willis presented for the Board's consideration of approval an amendment of the
Zoning Ordinance provisions relating to telecommunication towers. Concerns had been identified by the
County Commissioners at their meeting held on September 3. Mary Willis responded to those concerns.
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Willhoit to
delete from Section 8.8.17a.2 the words "A bond or other security" and replace with "A letter of credit".
VOTE: UNANIMOUS
A motion was made by Commissioner Willhoit, seconded by Chair Carey to approve the
proposed amendment with the following revisions:
1. Revise the Permitted Use Table and Article 6.18 to specify that stealth towers 75 feet or
shorter are permitted by right in certain zoning districts provided that provisions of Article 6.18 are met.
Article 6.18 requires that the tower be adequately disguised to minimize visual impact.
2. Insert the following as 8.8.17a.1 i) Additional Information:
The Special Use Permit application shall include a statement that the facility and
its equipment will comply with all federal, state and local emission requirements.
3. Insert the following as 8.8.17a2n) Standards of Evaluation and change previous n) to 0):
A determination shall be made that the facility and its equipment will comply with
all federal, state and local emission requirements, and the Special Use Permit shall include a
statement that the facility and its equipment will comply with all federal, state and local emission
requirements.
VOTE: AYES, 3; NOS, 2 (Commissioners Gordon and Halkiotis)
For the record, Commissioner Gordon voted against this amendment because of the lack of
encouragement for collocation of towers and also because she believes there is not enough protection
for the homeowner with respect to the location of a telecommunication tower nearby. Commissioner
Halkiotis voted against this proposal because he is opposed to having towers within two miles of each
other.
b. Reconsideration of Sibling Pine Estate Preliminary Plan
On September 3, 1996, the Board of Commissioners approved Sibling Pine Estate
Preliminary Plan with the condition that the lots be redesigned to eliminate the need for the strips
connecting the buildable portions of lots 6 and 7 to their respective drainfields and repair areas. The
applicant requested that the Board reconsider its action. The decision of the Board may be reconsidered
under certain circumstances if so requested by a Commissioner who voted with the majority.
A motion was made by Commissioner Halkiotis, seconded by Chair Carey to reconsider the
action that was taken on this item on September 3, 1996.
VOTE: AYES, 3; NOS, 2 (Commissioners Gordon and Willhoit)
Steve Yuhasz made comments on behalf of the owner and developer. He said that this
proposal is in accordance with the Zoning Ordinance. The arrangement of this property does maximize
the area for septic systems which have been approved by the Orange County Health Department. The
main reason he wants the plan approved is that this is how the family members want it developed. The
family acknowledged that they do understand and will abide by the restrictions placed on this
development.
A motion was made by Commissioner Crowther, seconded by Commissioner Halkiotis to
approve the Planning Board recommendation as stated in the agenda and in the resolution of approval.
Commissioner Gordon noted that she favored the Planning Staff recommendation which
included the condition adopted by the Commissioners on September 3.
VOTE: AYES, 4; NOS, 1 (Commissioner Gordon)
C. Community School for People Under Six Funding Request
Anna Mercer-McLean made reference to the expansion of their facility and explained that
because of zoning compliance requirements, the extra cost will range from $15,000 to $20,000.
The County Commissioners asked for additional information and said that this item will be
placed on the next agenda for further discussion.
10. REPORTS
a. Report _ Potential Residential Districts for Commissioner Elections
The Board considered a draft of potential Residential Districts for future election of County
Commissioners. Under this proposal, the current staggered terms and partisan primary process would
continue to apply. The County would be divided into five Residential Districts of roughly-equal population
with approximately 18,770 citizens and each district would be represented by one seat on the Board. All
registered voters in the County would be eligible to vote on all candidates in the years they represent
their party in a general election. Only registered voters of a particular party would vote on candidates in
their party in the primary election. In creating Residential Districts, census data is the accepted
standard for reliable information to ensure equally-proportioned districts. To create a draft of potential
Residential Districts, Planning staff has utilized a demographic software program to configure five
districts of roughly-equal population using 1990 Census data.
Geoffrey Gledhill distributed copies of the General Statutes that are pertinent to this issue.
He explained the process that must be followed in order to initiate such a change. It starts with
developing districts which is what the Board has before it tonight. The County Commissioners would
adopt a resolution outlining the specific districts and it would then be presented for voter approval. If it
receives voter approval, then there are other procedural steps that would need to be followed. He said
that the districts should be equal in population when first defined, however, when the Commissioners
redefine the districts, they do not have to be equal in population.
Commissioner Gordon said she feels that in this proposal the districts have no political
coherence; who would a commissioner from any given district represent? She does not believe this is a
step forward.
Chair Carey feels that this would increase the probability that citizens who live in rural areas
will have a reasonable chance of being elected.
Commissioner Halkiotis feels this is a good start.
Patrick Mulkey suggested not counting in the districts the citizens who cannot vote. Geoffrey
Gledhill said that this could not legally be done.
Bill Thorpe from Chapel Hill said that he feels drawing district lines will further divide the
people in this County. He is particularly concerned that minorities might be under represented. He is
against this plan.
Commissioner Gordon noted that no current commissioner resides within the town limits of
either Chapel Hill or Carrboro.
Bob Strayhorn feels that a seven member board may make a difference.
Commissioner Crowther and Commissioner Halkiotis said that they may work on a plan that
has seven districts. It was decided that this item will not again appear on an agenda unless it is
requested by a County Commissioner.
11. APPOINTMENTS -NONE
12. MINUTES -NONE
13. CLOSED SESSION
To consult with the County Attorney pursuant to N.C. Gen. Stat. Section 143-318.11(a)(3) in the
matters of Nello Teer v. Orange County et al
This item was postponed to the next meeting
14. ADJOURNMENT
With no further items to consider, Chair Carey adjourned the meeting. The next meeting will
be held on October 15, 1996 at 7:30 p.m. at the OWASA Operations Center in Carrboro, North Carolina.
Moses Carey, Jr., Chair
Beverly A. Blythe, Clerk