HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda - 04-20-2010 - 6aORANGE COUNTY
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
ACTION AGENDA ITEM ABSTRACT
Meeting Date: April 20, 2010
Action Agenda
Item No. ~_
SUBJECT: Shuttle Transportation for Low-Income Orange County Residents for Job
Related Activities
DEPARTMENT: Social Services PUBLIC HEARING: (Y/N) Yes
ATTACHMENT(S):
Title VI Public Document
Public Notification
Orange County Map
Job Access & Reverse Commute
(JARC) Application
INFORMATION CONTACT:
Yvette Smith, 245-2885
Jackie Terrell, Essential Transportation
Services, 452-1092
PURPOSE: To receive public comments on a proposal from Essential Transportation Services
(ETS) to provide transportation services for job related activities to low-income residents in
Orange County under the administration of the Orange County Department of Social Services,
and to authorize staff to proceed with the project if funded through a Job Access and Reverse
Commute (JARC) grant from the North Carolina Department of Transportation.
BACKGROUND: Recipients of services from the Orange County Department of Social
Services (DSS) are in critical need of safe and reliable transportation services for job related
activities which would ultimately fulfill the goal of self-sufficiency. The proposed project, if
funded through a Job Access and Reverse Commute (JARC) grant from the North Carolina
Department of Transportation, would address this much needed gap in service for Orange
County low-income residents.
DSS's role in the project would be as follows:
(1) Provide assistance to the mobility manager who would coordinate transportation services
to the Work First Program's rotating three month life skills program. Services would be
provided from 7 a.m. - 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. - 7 p.m. and includes transportation to and from
the Orange County facilities. ETS would provide door to door services for participants and
be available via dispatch for on-demand services throughout the day.
(2) Provide assistance to the mobility manager to provide transportation to participants in
Work Experience Sites and Job Search during the hours of 9 a.m. - 4 p.m. ETS would
provide transport for recipients within a 15 mile radius of their place of residence, i.e.
Mebane residents would be placed within Mebane and not be required to come to Chapel
Hill for employment.
2
(3) ETS will provide services to residents qualifying at 150% of poverty. The mobility manager
would work with case workers to conduct an assessment of the employed and how best to
use transportation services through activities such as travel/training. These services would
be conducted from 5 a.m. - 9 a.m. and 3 p.m. - 7 p.m. in the form of a connector route to
already established routes by Orange Public Transportation and Triangle Transit. ETS
would also be available for on demand services after 7 p.m. DSS would determine
eligibility of applicants at 150% of poverty and administer the voucher program through
vouchers provided by ETS under. the terms of the JARC grant. Applicants would be
expected to fund 50°I° of the service.
FINANCIAL IMPACT: The project is contingent upon receipt by ETS of a Job Access and
Reverse Commute (JARC) grant from the North Carolina Department of Transportation. There
is no cost to the County as ETS will provide the necessary funds for the local match.
Staff believes this project will reduce County staff time and associated costs equivalent to 1 full
time equivalent position for a savings of $42,667 per year. Receipt of the grant by and services
through Essential Transportation Services would also allow DSS to return a County van to the
County motor pool for a savings of $7,644 annually.
RECOMMENDATIONS}: The Manager recommends that the Board:
1. Receive Public Comments;
2. Close Public Hearing;
3. Approve the application for the transportation services provided by ETS (if funded by the
JARC grant); and
4. if the grant is awarded, authorize staff to negotiate an Agreement with ETS, subject to
review by the County Attorney, and authorize the County Manager to sign the
Agreement.
3
Voluntary Title VI Public Involvement
Title VI of the Civil Right's Act of 1964 requires North Carolina Department of
Transportation to gather statistical data on participants and beneficiaries of the agency's
federal-aid highway programs and activities. The North Carolina Department of
Transportation collects information on race, color, national origin and gender of the
attendees to this public meeting to ensure the inclusion of all segments of the population
affected by a proposed project.
The North Carolina Department of Transportation wishes to clarify that this information
gathering process is completely voluntary and that you are not required to disclose the
statistical-data requested in order to participate in this meeting. This form is a public
document.
The completed forms will be held on file at the North Carolina Department of
Transportation. For Further information regarding this process please contact Sharon
Lipscomb, the Title VI Manager at telephone number 919.508.1808 or email at
slipscomb@ncdot. gov.
Project Name: Date•
Meeting Location:
Name (please print)
Gender:
^ Male ^ Female
General ethnic identification Cate ories (check one)
^ Caucasian His anic American ^ American Indian/Alaskan Native
^ African American ^ Asian/Pacific Islander Other:
Color: National Oriein:
After you complete this form, please fold it and place it inside the designated box on the
registration table.
Thank you for your cooperation.
4
Important -A public hearing MUST be conducted whether or not requested by the Public.
PUBLIC HEARING RECORD
APPLICANT: Essential Transportation Services
DATE: April 20, 2010
PLACE: Orange County
TIME:
How many BOARD MEMBERS attended the public hearing?
How many members of the PUBLIC attended the public hearing?
Public Attendance Surveys
^ (Attached)
^ (Offered at Public Hearing but Wane completed)
I, the undersigned, representing (Legal Name ofApplicant) do hereby certify to the North
Carolina Department of Transportation, that a Public Hearing was held as indicated above and
During the Public Hearing
^ (NO public comments)
^ (Public Comments were made and meeting minutes
will be submitted after board approval)
The estimated date for board approval of meeting minutes is:
Signature of Clerk to the Board
Printed Name and Title
Affix Seal Here
Date
PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE
This is to inform the public that a public hearing will be held on the proposed Targeted Transit Assistance
Program (Section 5316) Application to be submitted to the North Carolina Department of Transportation
no later than March 31, 2010. The public hearing will be held on Apri120, 2010 at 7:00 p.m. before the
Orange County Board of Commissioners.
The Section 5316 grant application seeks funds to assist in developing new or expanded transportation
services such as shuttles, vanpools, guaranteed rides home or connector/feeder services that connect
welfare recipients and/or low-income employees to jobs and other employee-related services. Reverse
commute services are also covered under this program. This application may be inspected at the Orange
County Department of Social Services at 113 Mayo Street from 8:30-5:00, Monday -Friday. Written
comments should be directed to Yvette Smith at the Orange County Department of Social Services.
The total estimated amount requested for the period July 1, 2010 through June 30, 2012
Project Total Amount Local*Share
Capital $541,170 $54,117
(Vehicles & Other)
Operating $340,559 $170,280
TOTAL $881,729 $224,397
*Total local share will be provided by Essential Transportation Services
I' I
I_-~
I
.,
i
~1. : .
II
1.
- I 1;
1 ~
I 1 .
1
fF~
1 t~E I
g;~ :l;4
I,~
I ~
tl
m \
l
` 1 _
,
1
m
e
i
i
I ~
i
~~ ~
I
_..~
---~- -
-;
~ -
Q,
®........~,,..M.
v
a m~,
-- ~::~~.
o - -
=,;,=
__~_
- -
~„~~a~
Fi` ... m
o .., m
ORANGE COUNTY
NORTH CAROLINA -
NORTN CIIROLINq DEPARTMENT OF TRANBPORTgT10N
BLgiE PDAO FNMIEIMNCE UMT~MMRegi MIE MFORFMTON BECTroN
V.B. CEFMTMEN! DF TMx W OBigTgN
Rql NgMMwMMMeiMDON
V/
7
PART 1- Applicant Information
INSTRUCTION -Click On the gray rectangle (or use TAB key to navigate through the document after
clicking gold lock icon on toolbar}. When the gray rectangle turns to black begin typing. The text
will automatically wrap to the next row as you type. The answer may wrap to the next page
if necessary
A. CONTACT
Legal Name: Essential Transportation Services, Inc.
Address: P.O. Box 323
Morrisville State: N.C. Zi Code: 27560
Coun Wake Con ressional District:
Contact Person: Steven Ward and Lesia Ward
Tele hone: Area Code: 919 Phone Number: 824 -8460
Fax: 919-336-3140
E-mail: info@essentialtransportation.com Website:
www.essentialtrans ortation.com
Federal ID Number: ~
IMPORTANT: This section must be completed to have the aP~ication reviewed ___
1. Are you the designated recipient for the Community Transportation Program (CTP) OR a
designated duected recipient of federal funding? ^ YES X^ No
2. If yes, have you or will you apply for funds for activities or projects also being applied for here?
Please indicate which
^ FY 2011 CTP application- --NNNp ^ have applied ^ will apply
^ pRRA______~_____w_ ^ have applied ^ will apply
^ 5307 ------------------------------------^ have applied ^ will apply
3. If yes describe what services, products, functions, activities etc. are in both applications?
B. PURPOSE
Applicant's Mission The mission of the Essential Transportation Service, Inc. (ETS) is to
Statement provide quality transportation services in the Triangle area. ETS
emphasizes customer satisfaction, accessibility, comfort and safety while
providing eco-friendly buses as an environmental concern, policy
awareness through giving back to the community and community
engagement through serving the public.
8
Target Populations
Served by the Applicant
The Durham Chapel Hill Carrboro localized plan identifies the western
part of the Research Triangle Park area comprised of all of Durham
County, Orange County (this includes the towns of Chapel Hill, Carrboro,
and Hillsborough) and northeast Chatham County as the region
responsible for developing a coordinated regional public transit-human
services transportation plan.
ETS seeks to provide job related transportation services for the Orange
County Department of Social Services' (OCDSS) low-income program and
to implement a coordinated transportation plan linking the county to the
existing services provided by Triangle Transit and Orange Public
Transportation. The OCDSS serves the following communities: Chapel
Hill, Cazrboro, Hillsborough, Cedar Grove, Efland, Mebane, Rougemont,
residents on the Durham County/Orange County line and portions of
Alamance County.
Low income families in Orange and North Chatham County are faced
with several major obstacles in obtaining and retaining employment.
OCDSS has identified transportation needs in four areas of support for its
low-income clients: the Work First Enrichment Program, a three month
life skills training program at OCDSS; job search mandated for its clients
to continue receiving services; (3) transportation to volunteer worksites
for on the job training skills, and (4) provision of vouchers to former
TANF and other low income workers to keep them employed and reduce
the number of applicants returning to the system. Orange County's
statistics are impressive. The county ranks 10~ in the state in family
income. Fifty-one percent of the adult population have a college education
(highest in the state); 87.6 percent of the population earned a high school
diploma, and the county's per capita income is $41,435. Thus, low income
residents in Orange County are competing for jobs with a highly skilled
workforce. Typical jobs obtained by them do not provide a living wage;
the mean cost of a home in Orange County is $382,000 and the median
price is $250,OOO.On average, OCDSS clients make $7.50 per hour. Both
the limited availability and the high cost of transportation is a major
barrier to become self-sufficient. Safe, reliable, and inexpensive transport
is critical for economic mobility for low-income residents of Orange and
Chatham County. Furthermore, the lack of daycare and transportation for
second and third shift work compounds the obstacles. Most OCDSS
clients are women (95 percent), 50 percent are under age 30, 50 percent
have a high school diploma, and 47 percent of participants live in North
Orange County as of October 2009. Families living outside of the Chapel
Hill Transit System still face transportation issues. New services to the
County would benefit residents living outside of the present route and
reduce the number of cars on the roads in the County.
Product or Services ETS proposes to provide expanded geographical coverage through
Provided or Produced infra-county and cross county services, a guaranteed ride home service
including late-nights, holiday and weekend service, and to provide a
9
voucher program to transport low-income and welfare recipients to job
related activities. It also seeks to improve the transportation services for
Orange, and north Chatham County via the efforts of a mobility manager
who would perform the following duties: coordinate the development of
a streamlined website for all transportation services in each county; work
with officials to develop a universal fare card transferrable to the three
counties, develop individual transportation plans with new routes
outlines for pazticipants, and coordinate with student interns (from Duke
University, North Carolina Central University and the University of
North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Durham Technical College and Orange
Community College) recruited to work on promotion of the new routes
and acounty-wide proposed "Bus to Work Week". These latter measures
would improve public perception of public transportation. Finally, the
mobility manager would employ the use of Geographic Information
System tools and Intelligent Transportation to improve targeted area
transportation services.
10
PART 3 -Project Description
IMPORTANT -The FTA requires that projects receiving funds under Sections 5310 (Elderly and
Persons with Disabilities, Section 5316 (Job Access and Reverse Commute) and Section 5317 (New
Freedom) meet the needs that were described in the approved locally developed public transportation
human service coordinated plan.
A, PROJECT NEED/GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
1. Describe the tazget population for whom the unmet transportation needs as listed in the
approved local coordinated transportation plan for your area that this project seeks to
address.
Answer:
The Durham Chapel Hill Carrbom localized plan identifies the western part of the Research
Triangle Park area comprised of all of Durham County, Orange County (including the towns of
Chapel Hill, Carrboro, and Hillsborough), and Northeast Chatham County as the region
responsible for developing a coordinated regional public transit-human services transportation
plan.
ETS proposes to coordinate with the Orange County Department of Social Services (OCDSS) as
the lead agency to provide transportation services under the directives of the JARC program and
to provide a connector route from the towns of Mebane, Efland, Cedar Grove, Rougemont,
Alamance, and outer Hillsborough as a connector to the established route provided by Orange
Public Transportation(OPT).
Low income families in Orange and North Chatham County are faced with several major
obstacles in obtaining and retaining employment. The county ranks 10'~ in the state in family
income, 51 percent of the adult population have a college education (highest in the state), 87.6
percent of the population earned a high school diploma, and the per capita income is $41,435.
Thus, low income residents in Orange County are competing for jobs with a highly skilled
workforce. Jobs typically obtained by them do not provide a living wage since the mean cost of
a home in Orange County is $382,000 and the median price is $250,000. On average, OCDSS
clients make $7.50 per hour. Both the limited availability and the high cost of transportation is a
major barrier to become self-sufficiency. Also, these rural areas frequently lack sidewalks, and
it is unsafe for families to walk along the roads with small children in tow.
OCDSS has identified transportation needs in four areas of support for its low-income clients:
(1) the Work First Enrichment Program, a three month life skills training program at OCDSS;
(2)job seazch mandated for its clients to continue receiving services; (3) transportation to
volunteer worksites for on the job training skills, and (4) provision of vouchers to former TANF
and other low income workers to keep them employed and reduce the number of applicants
returning to the system.
The goal of ETS is to establish a connector route to fill the gap in service area originating in
Hillsborough and extending to Mebane as Orange Public Transportation and Triangle Transit
(TTA route #420) serve the area between Chapel Hi11 and Hillsborough (including downtown
Chapel Hill and UNC Hospital). In addition, service will be provided to the residents in these
rural areas who are clients of OCDSS requiring door -to-door service, on demand response, ~ 1
transportation to work sites, and employment search. Forty-eight percent of Work First clients
spend 0 - 6 months on Work First. The State allows up to 5 years of public assistance and
OCDSS works to avoid an applicant becoming a repeat recipient. Self-sufficiency for these
workers is heavily dependent upon safe, reliable and affordable transportation
2. Plan Information: Required:
ETS will address the following priorities as described by the project planning team:
1. Hire aMobility Manager.
2. Provide infra-county and cross-county services.
3. Provide an evening service and late night service (10pm- midnight) as needed.
4. Work to establish a universal fare card that works on all services.
5. Provide travel training for customers.
ETS will work closely with OCDSS in planning efficient travel routes and to provide travel
training for the targeted population to maximize service quality under this project. This can be
achieved by allowing the four targeted groups to schedule similar trips at the same time. For
example, persons enrolled in volunteer work and job search could be placed in the same area for
employment, if they live in the same county. OCDS5 prefers participants to find employment
in the same counties where they reside as this makes transportation easy to coordinate.
Answer:
1 Name of Plan/Title Durham Cha el Hill Carrboro MPO lan
2 Page Number pa a 21
(where unmet needs are listed) g
3 ~ Approval Date ~ 2009
3. Describe how this project will produce measurable difference(s) in meeting the defined unmet
transportation needs.
Answer: This project proposes to expand geographical coverage of Orange County's current
transportation plan to include Efland, Mebane and Cedar Grove . Affordable transportation is a
barrier to low- income residents. ETS proposes to provide a voucher program to transport low-
income and welfare recipients to job related activities to be administered by the Work First
program at OCDSS. The number of vouchers utilized would serve as a measurable and
reportable output. The mobility manager would provide travel training to increase use and
knowledge of public transportation availability. Another item is the decrease in repeat clients to
the Work First program due to unreliable and non-existent transportation as a direct cause of job
Loss. OCDSS will track the number of vouchers it provides to former TANF clients while the
mobility manager will target the number of one way trips coming through dispatch and the
numbers of persons trained, the number of web hits and the number of units added through
improved customer knowledge after implementing the Triangle wide "Bus to Work Week" as a
measure to reduce the number of vehicles on highways and as a way to gauge customer feelings
regazding mass transit.
Estimate the annual number of new people served, the number of trips that will be provided from the
proposed. project, and the average cost per trip. A trip is counted each time a passenger boards a
vehicle no matter how many vehicles are used to travel from origin to destination.
Answer (new people):
Answer (total trips):
Answer (average cost per trip):
WILL INCLUDE NUMBERS FROM DURHAM/CHAPELHILL LOWINCOMEAGENCIES
4. Describe the specific community (county) this project will serve, and provide pertinent
demographic data and/or maps.
Answer:
Orange County has a population of 131,123. Currently, there are 7,500 medicaid cases,
3,800 adults in the Food Nutrition program with an expected growth of 25 - 35 percent
month growth. 95 percent of the enrollees are women with children.
Target Groups Percentage of
the Service Area
population
Specific Descriptive Notes
Racial/Ethnic population 22.4 % 2009 Census estimate
Low income 14 % 2000 Census estimate
Elderly 15 % 2009 Census estimate
Disabled
Medicaid Recipients 6 % 2010 Work First roll for Orange County
Specify Other
5. Which of the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) defined goals will this proposed project help
to meet? See Appendix A
Answer.
Expand Extend Improve Improve Improve Remove
geographic Hours/days of system access/ customer barriers to
covera a service ca aci connections knowled a mobili
X^ X^ XQ X^ X^ x^
Specify
Other ~
B. IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
I . List/describe additional key personnel needed to implement this project and the applicant's ability
to manage the project.
Answer:
ETS is owned and operated by Lesia and Steven Ward. Lesia Ward has a Bachelor of Arts degree in
Business Administration. She is a 1993 graduate of North Carolina Central University in Durham.
Steven Ward has 22 years of service with the National Guazd and 17 years as a driver with United
Parcel Service (UPS). Lesia Ward will serve as project manager for the duration of the project. She
12
13
will be supervise the overall project and provide overall coordination of the project. Steven Ward
drives as needed for ETS and coordinate driver schedules.
Position and Title List up to 5 Key responsibilities by priority
Mobile 1 Coordinate with local officials and policy makers as
Manager needed
2 Provide travel training
3 Improve customer knowledge of transit available
1
4 Publicity and marketing of new services available
5 Work with Orange County Work First program to
coordinate all services as contracted
Project 1 Oversee project and implement recommendations as
Manager advised by mobility manager and management
consultant
2 Oversee drivers and other personnel
3 Assist with overall coordination of capital equipment
2 is ordered, delivered and ready by established
deadlines
4Visit work employer work sites to publicize new
service
Management 1 Track customer needs and satisfaction through survey
Consultant 2 Monitor and evaluate service provided
3 Track customer needs and usage on "Bus to Work
Week throughout Triangle area and make
3 recommendations to policy makers and local officials
4 Recruit interns from area universities and schools
5 Produce report on usage and needs of low income
residents and mass transit for area
2. Explain how this project is integrated into other s services or facilities provided by your agency.
Answer: Currently, ETS provides services to Campus Crossings, Duke University and North
Carolina Central University and businesses in the surrounding triad area. These services are
strictly shuttle services and does not require housing of staff. Office space will be used
primarily for mobilitymanager, dispatcher and meeting space for functions. All drivers will
be cross-trained on routes and receive driver training. The current maintenance worker will
service vehicles and ensure contracts are adhered to for maximum and safe vehicle
performance.
3. Describe what the applicant plans to do to assure that the funded services are provided
throughout the period of performance.
Answer: ETS will adhere to the timelines established in the project goals. The project team
composed of the mobility manager, project manager, management consultant and OCDSS will
work closely together to ensure participants are utilizing the service and that their individual
needs aze met.
4. Describe how the applicant will manage risk and provide for safe delivery of services or safe use
and maintenance of capital assets. (i.e. driver training, maintenance scheduling, and insurance)
Answer:
It is ETS policy to provide a safe, and secure mode of transport for its customers. ETS policy
mandates that all employees receive a drug screen and transit training. In addition, all drivers
must submit a clean driving record and provide proof of insurance as a condition of
employment. ETS produces a training manual for all employees and is updated annually as new
transportation materials become available by the North Carolina Department of Transportation
and policy changes within the Counties ETS operates.
14
ETS provides vehicle and property insurance as noted on submitted assurances documentation.