Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutAgenda - 03-05-2009 - 2 ORANGE COUNTY • BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS ACTION AGENDA ITEM ABSTRACT Meeting Date: March 5,2008 Action Agenda Item No. SUBJECT: Report on FY 2009-19 Recommended County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) Follow-Up Items DEPARTMENT: Budget PUBLIC HEARING: (YIN) No ATTACHMENT(S): To view the FY 2009-19 County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) go to www.co.orange.nc.us/budget/2009- 19ManagerRecommendedClP.asp INFORMATION CONTACT: Attachment 1. December 1, 2008 Agenda Laura Blackmon, (919) 245-2300 Abstract - Report on FY Donna Coffey, (919) 245-2151 2009-19 Recommended • County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) Follow-Up Items PURPOSE: To report on previously discussed FY 2009-19 recommended County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) items and prepare the Board to approve the CIP at the regular March 17, 2009 meeting. BACKGROUND: Commissioners and staff have discussed the Manager's Recommended FY 2009-19 CIP on a number of occasions since it was originally presented to the Board on October 28, 2008. The attached agenda materials from the Board's December 1, 2008 meeting responded to a number of items "flagged" by the Board during earlier CIP related work sessions. The December 11, 2008 Board minutes reflect additional information requested by the Board. • Twin Creeks Linear Park, Soccer Super Fund, Astroturf field at Cedar Falls and other Park Projects — During the February 10, 2009 work session, the Board received reports from staff regarding these projects. Staff is currently analyzing the outcome of the February 10 work session and will follow up with the Board at a future work session. Future CIP's will incorporate Board direction on these projects. • Implementation of the Library Task Force Report— The County's share of pay-as-you- • go capital funds is limited and for the most part, allocated to maintenance of existing facilities. This means funding for construction of new facilities such as the ones identified in the Library Services Task Force Report must come from issuance of debt in future years. Future CIP's will propose debt funding for these new facilities. 2 • Link Center Timeline and Project Scope - The Link Center is proposed as the location for administrative offices for the County Manager, County Attorney, Financial Services, • and Human Resources Departments. In addition, administrative offices and a boardroom for the County Commissioners is included in the design. Corley Redfoot Zack, the project architects, completed a significant portion of the office space design prior to the project being halted in 2008, pending release of funds to support the renovation. Soon after the summer break, assuming funding is released for FY 2009-2010, the County will re- engage the designer and schedule an interactive work session for Commissioners to discuss the design needs of the Boardroom. Planning for the Boardroom will include discussion with potential partners, such as the Town of Hillsborough and the Orange County Board of Education to ensure their comments are also considered in the room design. In addition to construction costs, funding in the CIP includes the design fees, all owner responsibility items, furnishings and the infrastructure for technology to support the Boardroom. Cost estimates will be provided throughout the design process to ensure the design correlates favorably to the available funding. • Alternatives for Funding Stabilization of Park Buildings (Other than Reallocating Monies from Link Center Renovations) — The December 1 agenda proposed funding stabilization of park buildings at Blackwood Farm and Millhouse Road Parks by deferring allocations to the Link Center Renovation Project in FY 2009-10. During the December 11 Commissioners asked staff to explore other funding alternatives. Given the limited pay-as-you-go capital revenues, staff has not been able to identify other opportunities to redirect pay-as-you-go funding to the stabilization projects. Timing of the Link Center renovations is such that spreading funding for the project over a two-year period should not adversely affect timely completion of the project. The Manager recommends the Board consider the following decision points on March 5 include: • Postpone 1-cent tax rate increase, effective July 1, 2009, to fund county facilities capital maintenance - In light of the Board's February 12, 2008 decision to maintain a revenue neutral tax rate for FY 2009-10, the Manager recommends postponing the 1- cent tax rate increase, effective July 1, 2009, to fund county facilities capital maintenance • Stabilization of Farmstead Stabilization Projects at Blackwood Farm at New Hope Park and Millhouse Road Park — The Manager's initial recommendation had been to redirect 2001 bond monies from Twin Creeks Park to Blackwood Farm and Millhouse Road Park projects. The Manager recommends the following funding alternative: o FY 2009-10 Recommendation - use $275,000 of the $850,000 allocated to the Link Center project to fund the farmstead stabilization projects at Blackwood Farm at New Hope Park and Millhouse Road Park o FY 2010-11 Recommendation — Replenish monies borrowed from Link Center in FY 2009-10 by postponing FY 2010-11 funding allocation for Courts and Detention Future Needs Project for one year • Note: Intended use of monies recommended for Courts and Detention Future Needs Project is planning and design of future facility needs. Postponement of funding for one year will not be detrimental to the project as a whole. 3 • This recommendation avoids redirecting 2001 bond monies originally • intended for Twin Creeks to Blackwood Farm and Millhouse Road Park • $1.2 million in Emergency Service Reserve for Emergency Services — The Manager recommends releasing these funds to be expended in accordance with the Emergency Services Directors list of needs included in the FY 2009-19 Recommended CIP FINANCIAL IMPACT: Financial impacts are included in the FY 2009-19 CIP and attachments to this agenda item. RECOMMENDATION(S): The Manager recommends the Board of County Commissioners receive this report regarding the FY 2009-19 Recommended County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) follow up items. • • ORANGE COUNTY • BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS ACTION AGENDA ITEM ABSTRACT Meeting Date: December 1, 2008 Action Agenda Item No. 7 SUBJECT: Report on FY 2009-19 Recommended County Capital Investment Plan (CrP) Follow-Up Items DEPARTMENT: Budget PUBLIC HEARING: (YIN) No ATTACHMENT(S): To view the FY 2009-19 County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) go to www.co.orange.nc.us/budget/2009- 19ManagerRecommendedClP.asp Attachment 1. Recommended Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Projects by Fiscal Year Attachment 2. Summary- FY 2009-19 Recommended Funding for • County Park Projects Attachment 3. Comparison of FY 2009-19 INFORMATION CONTACT: and FY 2008-18 Donna Coffey, (919) 245-2151 Recommended CIP Funding by Project Attachment 4. Summary of Library Services Task Force Recommendations Attachment 5. Cross-Reference FY 2008- 18 and FY 2009-19 Unfunded County Needs Attachment 6. Impact Statement of Postponing Central Permitting Technology Initiative PURPOSE: To report on previously discussed FY 2009-19 recommended County Capital Investment Plan (CIP) items. BACKGROUND: On November 13, 2008, Commissioners held a CIP work session and requested staff to provide additional information on a number of items. Items "flagged" by the Board include: • 2 Flagged Items Staff Analysis/Recommendation • FY 2009-10 Recommendation - use $275,000 of the $850,000 allocated to the Link Center project to fund the farmstead stabilization projects at Blackwood Farm at New Hope Park and Millhouse Road Park o Note— Recommended funding for Link Center Renovations project occurs over two years, FY 2009-10 and FY 2010-11 • FY 2010-11 Recommendation— Replenish monies borrowed from Link Center in FY Identify funding alternatives in FY 2009-10 2009-10 by postponing FY 2010-11 funding for stabilization of farmstead structures at allocation for Courts and Detention Future Blackwood Farm at New Hope Park and Needs Project for one year Millhouse Road Park o Note: Intended use of monies recommended for Courts and Detention' Future Needs Project is planning and design of future facility needs. Postponement of funding for one year will not be detrimental to the project as a whole. • This recommendation avoids redirecting • 2001 bond monies originally intended for Twin Creeks to Blackwood Farm and Millhouse Road Park Identify, by year, which ADA projects will be completed with recommended funding See Attachment 1 levels Clarify park project priorities Spring 2009 work session (Attachment 2 of this agenda abstract summarizes park projects included in the recommended CIP) Update of Efland Sewer project Update provided at November 24, 2008 Quarterly Public Hearing Identify projects where recommended funding has increased from FY 2008-18 See Attachment 3 recommended CIP Provide copy of Library Services Task Force Attachment 4 provides the Executive Summary recommendations of the most recent report from the County's Library Services Task Force Change title of Reserve for Future Land Changes will occur in printed version of Purchases to Reserve for Future Lands approved FY 2009-19 CIP and all future CIP Legacy and Land Purchases documents Information Technology (IT) Strategic Plan To be provided at BOCC December 11, 2008 Regular Meeting • Policy for use of Public Art Reserve To be discussed at a future BOCC work session 3 Flagged Items Staff Analysis/Recommendation • Construction of building addition at Efland Staff will explore need prior to presentation of FY Community Center 2010-2020 Recommended CIP Cross reference unfunded needs from last year See Attachment 5 Determine date for soft opening for Northern Manager working with Parks and Recreation Park Director re: proposed dates Provide information regarding impact of not See Attachment 6 funding central permitting soon • In addition, speakers at the November 18, 2008 public hearing urged Commissioners to fund the following items: • Synthetic turf at Cedar Falls Park and Smith Middle School • Additions to Chapel Hill Carrboro City Schools Carrboro High School • Lake Orange automatic valve controls (Note: Recommended CIP includes funding in FY 2009-10 to install these controls) • Continued funding of Conservation Easement and Lands Legacy projects It is important to note the County's Capital Investment Plan (CIP) is a comprehensive multi-year plan • for investing in future County and Schools' capital needs in a strategic, "big picture" manner. The CIP is considered a "living plan", meaning that each year, staff and the Board can reassess needs identified in the previous year's plan to determine if future needs remain the same as those outlined in previously approved plans. If needs and priorities change from year-to-year, the Board can make appropriate revisions to previously adopted/approved plans to accommodate new priorities and projects. Decision points for the Board's consideration on December 11 will include: • Whether to implement a 1-cent tax rate increase, effective July 1, 2009, to fund county facilities capital maintenance • Consideration of recommended funding alternative for stabilization of buildings at Blackwood Farm at New Hope Park and Mitlhouse Road Park (see first item in chart on page 2 of this agenda abstract) • Whether to appropriate $1.2 million in Emergency Service Reserve for Emergency Services needs or to retain monies in reserve pending outcome of upcoming Fire and Rescue Study • Timeline for completing Link Center Renovations FINANCIAL IMPACT: Financial impacts are included in the FY 2009-19 CIP and attachments to this agenda item. RECOMMENDATION(S): The Manager recommends the Board of County Commissioners receive this report regarding the FY 2009-19 Recommended County Capital Investment Plan (CIP)follow up items. • 0__ • 0 , , • • FY 2006 FY 2009- FY 2010- FY 2011- FY 2012- FY 2013- FY 2014 FY 2015-„FY 2016- FY 2017- FY 2018- PRIORITY LOCATION/ITEM 09 10 11 12 _ 13 14 15 16 _ 17 _ 18 19 1"' RICHARD E.WHiTTED HUMAN SERVICES CENTER Accessible parking and route into building Re troom modifications for ADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.) Reconfigure restroom layout for accessibility(stall dividers,grab bars,fixtures,supply/waste lines) 2 SOUTHERN HUMAN SERVICES CENTER Accessible parking and route Into building(resbipe spaces,modify sidewalks,add curb cuts) liffI$it 6531 I I .1 I 1 I I L I I 3 ORANGE COUNTY JAIL Elevator modernization I I It3$.0;00A $3000gl I I I j J I I 1 NEW COURTHOUSE(1954) Restroom modifications for ADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.)m PZINS. Reconfigure restroom layout for accessibility(stall dividers,grab bars,futures,supply/waste lines)m k ,; yT Replace restroom doors&frames with compliant width(includes modifications to masonry walls)PI K 'V . ,_.,..r. Elevator modernization 0 0 00 v $3D,000 2 HISTORIC COURTHOUSE Accessible parking and route into building(restripe spaces,replace existing ramp) ,4x;$6,000 P (grab protection,etc.) A j;s$i .06. Restroom modifications for ADA compliance cab bars,fixtures,scald rolection,eta $630p; $SDUOD Elevator modernization 3 COURT STREET ANNEX Accessible parking and route into building WAVY Restroom modifications for ADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.) 'AMU 1 OO Reconfigure restroom layout for accessibility(stall dividers,grab bars,fixtures,supplyAvaste lines) ( A?sjo00_ 1 JOHN LINK GOVERNMENT SERVICES CENTER Accessible parking and route into building(restripe parking spaces,curb cuts,walkway modifications) „t,$$5000 Restroom modifications forADA compliance(scald protection) f$1000 • Elevator modernization I $50;p00 3 PLANNING&AGRICULTURE BUILDING Accessible parking and route into building(new ramp,new walkways,new parking pad) ;Ii$30 Opli I I Restroom modifications forADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.) $15;000 501 WEST FRANKLIN ST Accessible parking and route into building(new ramp) ;ti2D00. Restroom modifications for ADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.) I ff .$2,:500; I } 1 GOVERNMENT SERVICES ANNEX • Accessible parking and.route into building(new/modified ramp) liTIOPI000� /'� Restroom modifications for ADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.) „; $2,100 / ,� 2 PUBLIC WORKS ADMINISTRATION BUILDING • \�j.J) Accessible parking and route into building(new/modified ramp,remark parking spaces) 6Ip,000 Restroom modifications forADA compliance(grab bars,fixtures,scald protection,etc.) j it 3 MOTOR POOL FACILITY Accessible parking and route into building(remark parking spaces) I f I I I I 150:5010.01 0001 I I I I • • • FY 2008- FY 2009- FY 2010- FY 2011- FY 2012- FY 2013- FY 2014• FY 2015- FY 2016 FY 2017- FY 2018- 13 14 •15 16 17 18 19 PRIORITY LOCATION/ITEM 09 10 11 12 ; 6000 • Restroom modifications for ADA compliance(scald protection) • 3?'.a%*-� rs Sr :d"'s-,•r •1.-a-r9-ITD ••1 . c:SEN D- ENTERS=° Ent.c a ��`: 1 CENTRAL RECREATION BUILDING I I (rx}$]0;000( I I I I I I I Accessible parking and mute into building(provide additional parking spaces) _ irctxT `ax I • I I I I 1.540.0. 0I Restroom modifications for ADA compliance(scald protection) I• I I I TOTAL $81 653 $81,653 $131,653 $181,653 $231,653 $281,653 $331,653 $381 653 $50,000 $50,000 $481,653 $531,653 CUMM TOTAL . NOTES: e Whined Center was previously identified as the highest priority location for correcting ADA deficiencies. Current and future plans for relocation of agencies from the Whiffed Center to Hillsborough Commons has changed the priority of the Whiffed Center. 2) Items identified address accessibility into buildings and restrooms at these facilities.They do not address all ADA deficiencies for the identified facilities. 3) New Courthouse restroom modificationsfimprovements to be completed as part of scheduled renovation project. 4)The list of projects identified here does not address all deficiencies at all County buildings.Rather,it includes priority projects to allow handicapped individuals to park(in identified,compliant parking spaces)and access(via walkways,ramps,exterior doors, etc.)primary entrances for select buildings. • • • N • . . III■ • . . ' _ . . . • . Attachment 2 ' - 121012008 Attachment 2. Summary-FY 2009-19 Recommended Funding for County Park Projects Budgeted Total Project • Project Revenues By Fiscal Year Funding 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012.13 2013-14 2014.15 2015-16 2016-17 2017.18 2018-19 Revenues 10101/08 Pay-As-You-Go Revenues Per Capital Funding Policy 0200 000 30 • S0 SO 50 50 30 30 50 SO 30 3200,000 NC Education Lottery 50 50 $0 50 $0_ $0 50 30 SO $0 $0 $0 Grants $500,000 $0 $0 $0 So_ 50 SO 50 $0 $0 $0 $500,000 Fees $0 . 30 ' 50 - $0 50 00 $0 $0 $0 30 SO SO Other 5223,005 $0 SO $0 • 50 SO 30 $0 $0 $0 . $5 $223,000 Total Pay-As-You-Go Revenues $923,000 $0_ SO Su_ SO_ SO So 50 SO $0 SO $923,000 Proceeds from Currently Programmed Debt • 1997 Bonds $0 30 $0 SO $0 30 50 $0 SO 50 50 S0 2001 Bonds 35,250,000 $0 $ 30 $0 30 SO $0 $0 SO $0 $5,250,000 2004 213 Net Debt Bonds $75,000 $0 SO 30 50 50 50 $0 50 $0 $0 $75,000 ' Alternative Financing 52,267.000 50 50 SO SO 00 50 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,267,000, Total Proceeds from Currently Programmed $7592,000 SO SO $5 $0 $0 $0 50 50 $0 $0 $7,692,000 Debt Future Debt 50 $0 $o $0 $100,000 $1,700,000 56 512,500 014,369.000 $8,745,000 57.200,000 56,700,000 $45,326,500 Unfunded 30 $0 $0 $0 $0 SO 50 $0 $0 50 so 00 Total County Park Revenues $8,515,000_ SO_ $0 SO $100,000 $1,700,000_ $6,512,500 514,369,000 $8,745,000_ $7,200,000 $6,700,000 $53,841,500, Recommended Project Appropriations By Fiscal Year Document Page Appropriations Expenditures and Available Total Protect FY 200B• FY 2008- Encumbrances , Appropriatlons 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2011-15 2015-16 2016-17 2017-10 2016.19 n.999 10181165 Appropdatlens 15 19 Through 10101108 10/01/08 •Bingham District Park 50 SO $0 50 50 SO $0 SO $0 $0 $0 36,500.000 • So $6,600,000 Appe d°( a Blackwood Farm 2-5 r New Hope 3225,000 $89,964 3135,016 $215,000 50 30 50 $450,000 $4,100,000 5250,000 s0 so 50 $5,240,000 Appends( 10 A• Falrvanx park 4 5& Development 3925,000 $161,185 $773,815 $0 $0 $0 $D 50 00 $10,000 $1,620,000 $0 $0 $2,555,000 Appends 30• An- - ds A Mltlhowa Road Park $50,000 $0 $50,000 $60,000 50 50 $0 $0 $1,000,000 $7,000,000 $200,000 $0 $0 $8,310,000 AppendIx 52 A Mountains to Sea Trail $0 50 50 50 50 $0 $0 $550,000 50 5109,000 $fi00,D00 3$ 50 $1,259,000 Ands Preserve Hope/Hollow R $0 $0 ;O $0 50 ;0 50 $0 $0 30 $625,000 50 $0 $026,000 Append« 56 Northeast Park $0 So $0 30 $0 $5 $0 so so $o so ;700,000 56.700,000 57,400,000 Appntrdo( 58 4-13 r `[1 \. Northern Park ;1,648,000 3155,265 51,692.735 50 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 50 30 $0 $1,648,000 Appendix 62- , 4-23 0 Twin Creeks Park 51,850,000 $212,314 51,637,688 ($275,000) $0 $0 $0 50 31,300,000 $6,000,000 55,700.000 00 50 $14,615,000 Appends 80 _ k Upper Eno Nature Appendk Preserve PubOc Access SD S0 $O $0 s0 $0 $0 $200,000 $112,500 $1,000,000 SD $0 '$0 $1,312,600 A 92 Ames _ 4-25 6 West Ten Park $3,617,000 $3,617,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $100,000 $500,000 50 30 $0 SO 50 54,217,000 Appends 84 - TotalCountyPark $8,515,000 $4,225,748 $4,289,252 $0 SA $0 $100,000 $1,700,000 $6,512,500 $14,369,000 $8,745,000 57,200,000 36,700,000 $53,641,500 Projects J Attachment 3 ��� 12/01/2008 Attachment 3. Comparison of FY 2009-19 and FY 2008-18 Recommended CIP Funding by III Project This chart cross references FY 2009-19 and FY 2008-18 total recommended funding for individual County capital projects Recommended Document Page References FY 2009-19 Total FY 2008-18 Total Project Title Project Funding Project Funding FY 2009-19 FY 2008-18 Recommendations _ Recommendations 1 Americans With Disabilities Act(ADA) $550,000 $550,000 2 5-3 Improvements 2 Animal Services(Existing Facility) $50,000 $0 4 Not Included Deconstruction 3 Animal Services Facility Construction $9,020,000 $8,870,000 6 2-3 4 Bingham District Park $6,500,000 $0 8 Appendix A s Blackwood Farm @ New Hope $5,240,000 $225,000 10 2-5&Appendix A 6 Capital Reserve for Emergency Repairs $675,000 $0 12 Not Included 7 Central Orange Senior Center $5,300,000 $5,254,350 14 2-9 8 County Campus&Library - $25,850,000 $25,700,000 16 2-13 County Facilities Capital Repairs& s $27,590,300 $8,891,100 18 5-11 &5-23 Replacements 10 County Telephone System Replacement $1,000,000 $850,000 20 2-15 III 11 Court Street Annex Renovations $125,000 $250,000 22 2-17 12 Court and Detention Future Needs $900,000 $6,200,000 24 5-7 13 Efland Sewer Extension Construction $4,855,000 $4,905,000 26 2-27 14 Emergency Services Reserve $4,710,000 $0 28 Not Included 15 Fairview Park Development $2,555,000 $925,000 30 4-5&Appendix A 16 Government Services Annex Renovations $200,000 $205,000 32 2+33 17 Heritage Center $147,930 $126,321 34 2-35 18 Human Services Offices&Clinics at $24,869,000 $8,700,000 36 5-13 Hillsborough Commons 15 Information Technology $11,900,000 $9,300,000 38 2-39 20 Jail(Existing) $1,375,000 $2,200,000 40 2-41 21 Justice Facility Expansion(including New $11,637,961 $11,637,961 42 2-43 Courthouse Renovations) 22 Lake Orange Capital Maintenance $390,000 $0 44 Not Included 23(Reserve for)Future Land Purchases $3,650,000 $2,885,000 46 5-9 24 Libraries-Future Facilities $3,050,000 $2,700,000 48 5-15 • Attachment 3 Page 1 of 2 �� Attachment 3 III t�� J 12/01/2008 Attachment 3. Comparison of FY 2009-19 and FY 2008-18 Recommended CIP Funding by Project This chart cross references FY 2009-19 and FY 2008-18 total recommended funding for individual County capital projects Recommended Document Page References FY 2009-19 Total FY 2008-18 Total Project Title Project Funding Project Funding FY 2009-19 FY 2008-18 Recommendations Recommendations 25 Link Center Renovations $1,300,000 $1,100,000 50 2-45 26 Millhouse Road Park $8,310,000 $50,000 52 . 4-11 &Appendix A 27 Mountains to Sea Trail $1,259,000 $0 54 Appendix A 28 New Hope/Hollow Rock Preserve $625,000 $0 56 Appendix A 2e Northeast Park $7,400,000 $0 58 Appendix A 3o Northern Human Services Center $714,545 $614,545 60 2-47&5-18 Renovations • 31 Northern Park $1,848,000 $1,848,000 62 4-13&AppendixA 32 Observation Well Network $180,000 $0 64 Not Included 33 Ozone Monitoring $35,000 $0 66 Not Included 34 Planning&Ag Building Renovations $550,000 $550,000 68 2-49 35 Public Art Reserve $305,000 $65,000 70 5-5 36 (Reserve for)Public Works Campus $1,170,000 $1,025,000 72 5-21 37 Register of Deeds Automation $1,800,964 $1,728,964 74 2-53 38 Southern Human Services Center Addition $6,050,000 $0 76 5-13 (including New Dental Clinic) 39 SportsPlex Facility Maintenance and $2,050,000 $1,000,000 78 5-25 Equipment Replacement ao Twin Creeks Park $14,575,000 $1,850,000 80 4-23&Appendix 41 Upper Eno Nature Preserve Public Access Areas $1,312,500 $0 82 Appendix A 42 West Ten Park $4,217,000 $3,617,000 84 4-25&Appendix A a3 Whitted Human Services Renovations for $400,000 $0 86 5-13 Health Department III Attachment 3 Page 2 of 2 CnrnewT • • • • ORANGE COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS • ACTION AGENDA ITEM ABSTRACT • Meeting Date: May 20, 2008 • Action Agenda Item No. 3- SUBJECT: . Presentation by the Library Services Task Force DEPARTMENT: Library PUBLIC HEARING:•(YIN) No ATTACHMENT(S): INFORMATION CONTACT: A.. Executive Summary Dr. Evelyn Daniel, Chair, Library B. Attachment 1 Services Task Force C. Attachment 2 Brenda Stephens, Director,.245-2528 • • PURPOSE: To present the 2007 Library Services Task Force Report Executive Summary outlining its recommendations, a follow-up report highlighting gaps and needs of the Library Services Standards for Orange County, and a facility needs update from the 2004 Library Services Task•Force. BACKGROUND: In January 2007, the BOCC formally re-convened a Library Services Task Force and provided it with the following charge: ® Review the report and recommendations of the Carrboro Library Workgroup (April 20, 2004); • Review the report and recommendations of the Library Services Task Force report of October 19, 2004 as they specifically relate to a "southwest regional branch library combining the collections, staff, and services presently located at McDougle Middle School and the Century Center Cybrary"; • Prepare and present to the BOCC a report which addresses in conjunction with Orange County management, the following concerns and considerations expressed by elected • and community leaders: Recommended Facility Size, Time Horizon for Facility Construction,funding Facility Construction. . • Report its recommendations to the BOCC for action in,context of capital investment program planning. At the December 3, 2007 BOCC meeting, the Library Service Standards, which are attached, and a Capital & Operational Needs Request were presented to the Board of County • Commissioners for acceptance. The information.was accepted by the BOCC, but the Service Standards were not formally adopted at that time. • • • • /0 The professionally trained librarians on the Task Force, directed by the BOCC and Task Force at large, have created a Matrix, which is attached, of Library Standards identifying those Orange County libraries that meet the standard or the financial impact of achieving the standard. FINANCIAL IMPACT: There is no immediate financial impact•to receiving this Executive Summary and Attachments. These documents identify specific•funding initiatives for the CIP for Library Services in Orange County. The BOCC would ultimately need to discuss and determine the overall magnitude and relative priority of these future capital project proposals and associated impacts on program operations and facility maintenance. The Library currently holds in trust approximately $129,000 that can be used as a capital contribution towards a proposed Heritage Center. Additionally, the current Library budget contains $10,000, earmarked to engage an outside consultant to explore interoperability among all Orange County Libraries. These funds can be used to address the 2000 Task Force recommendation to conduct a cost- benefit study of implementing a county-wide,jointly—operated,technology-system. RECOMMENDATION(S): The Manager recommends that the Board: 1. Accept the Library Service Standards and Facilities Needs Matrix developed by 2007 Library Services Task Force; and 2. Direct County and Library management to begin discussions with the Town of Chapel Hill for a consolidated county-wide library system. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • . Library Services Task Force Executive Summary • To the Commissioners: Thank you for your financial support and guidance for the series of'studies on libraries and services in Orange County beginning with the Task Force of 2002,the Task Force of 2004,the Carrboro Study Group,and the most recent Task Force of 2007. These local studies are combined with four recent national studies described below to form the knowledge base for comprehensive library service for the county. • A national survey of public attitudes toward libraries reported that the American people see libraries as political solutions to many pressing community problems, • such as universal access to computers and a safe place for teens. Libraries have high credibility;they are given the highest grade of any community institution. They perform an essential service in a trustworthy-manner;local libraries use money well.The general public values libraries as a safe central community gathering location. The public believes libraries should provide traditional services,such as books for children,reference materials,knowledgeable and friendly librarians as well as 2lst century services like computers and online services.' • o A national survey funded by the Institute for Museum and Library Services concluded that libraries evoke consistent,extraordinary public trust among diverse adult users,that the public benefits from the presence of libraries on the Internet,that available information inspires the search for more information,and that Internet use is positively related to in-person visits to libraries? • A 2007 survey by the Pew Internet&American Life Project reports that libraries drew visits from more than half the American population last year for a variety of purposes. Young adults were found to be the heaviest users of libraries for problem-solving purposes and other reasons? • • • • Two additional recent reports calculated taxpayer return on investment in Florida and Pennsylvania public libraries respectively. These studies used public library annual reports to the State Library,a statewide household telephone survey of adults,in-library surveys of adults,surveys of organizations and an input-output Long Overdue;A Fresh Look at Public Attitudes About Libraries in the 21"Century(2006).. Prepared by Public Agenda with support from the Americans fbr Libraries Council and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. Accessed 4/27/2008 from http://wwW.publicagenda.org/research/pdfs/long_overdue.pdf 2 Griffiths,Jose-Marie and Donald King(2008). InterConnections: The IMLS National Study on the Use .ofLibraries,Museums and the Internet. Funded by the Institute for Museum and Library Services. Accessed 4/27/2008 from http://interconnectionsreport.org/reports/ConclusionsFullRptB.pdf. 3 Estabrook,Leigh,Evans Witt and Leigh Rainey(2007). Information Searches That Solve Problems;How People Use the Internet,.Libraries,and Government Agencies when They need Help.(2007). Funded by the Pew Internet and American Life Project. Accessed 4/27/2008 from http://interconnectionsreport.org/reports/ConclusionsFullRptB.pdf. 1 • econometric model. The conclusion is that all taxpayers benefit from public libraries through their contribution to education,the economy,tourism, • retirement,and quality of life. Overall Florida's public libraries return$6.54 for every$1.00 invested from all sources;.the Pennsylvania ROI in public libraries is 5.5 to 1.45 • We used this knowledge base to develop three principles as the basis of our recommendations for library service in Orange County: • 1. a regional approach • 2. collaborative county-wide planning 3. a 3-5 year plan to address immediate needs. Using the first principle,we recommend that the county adopt a regional approach to library service: This translates to main libraries in Hillsborough and Chapel Hill and geographically located branches elsewhere,plus a Heritage Center in Hillsborough. Your acceptance of the attached facility requirements and the capital investment in the new main library building are steps in the fulfillment of this recommendation. The next step would be consolidation of the two small Carrboro facilities in a Southwest Branch, followed by a North/West expansion of the Northern Branch in Cedar Grove and the establishment of a West County Branch in Efland. Please see attachment(1)for a chart comparing where we are now to the recornniendations of the 4-year-old 2004 facilities plan. The second principle is continued growth in collaborative county-wide planning. The planning process underlying the several task forces has fostered a cooperative approach. The acceptance of a county library standard moves us forward on this goal. Attachment (2)shows what has been accomplished and what remains to be done in the achievement of this standard. Future initiatives,such as courier service among all.the libraries and interoperability of online public access catalogs,for example,are possible next steps. We recommend that the county investigate the advantages and disadvantages of a jointly operated technical support system using a common online public access catalog(OPAC) by engaging an expert to conduct a study of costs and alternatives. . • The third principle we recommend is the development of a 3-S year plan to address immediate needs. We recommend ongoing reviews of progress and plans using the two attached standards for facilities and services with consideration for changes in technology and current best practices,and information reports to the county commissioners. • "Griffiths,Jose-Marie;Donald W.King,Christinger Tomer,Thomas Lynch;Julie Harrington(2004). Taxpayer Return on Investment in Florida Public Libraries:Summal y Report. Funded by the Institute of Museum and Library Services and administered by the Florida Dept.of State,State Library and Archives of Florida. Accessed 4/28/2008 from http://dlis.dos.state.fl.us/bid/roi/pdfs/ROISummaryReport.pdf. 5 Griffiths,Jose-Marie;Donald W.King and Sarah Aemi(2006). Taxpayer Return-on-Investment(ROl)'in Pennsylvania Public Libraries. Funded by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Accessed 4/28/2008 from http://www.statelibrary.state.pa.us/libraries/lib/libraries/paroireportfinal7.pdf. • 2 • i . • • To summary,the immediate next steps that we recommend are the following: I. The establishment of the Heritage Center and the construction of a Southwest library branch. This should be followed as soon as possible by a North/West expansion of the Northern Branch in Cedar Grove and the establishment of a West County Branch in Efland. • 2. A study of the advantages and disadvantages of a county-wide jointly operated technical support system. Other mechanisms for collaborative • activities between the County library system and the Chapel Hill library should continue to be explored. 3. Ongoing reviews of progress toward meeting library facilities recommendations and service standards. • Submitted by the Library Services Task Force • • • • • • • • • • • 3 • • • . _ • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . • • . . . . . • . . . . . • ._ Library Services Task Force 2007-ATTACHMENT 1 Attachment 1 ' Orange County Library Facilities Chart . - . Central South East Region South West Region North Region West Region Main Library Chapel Hill Carrboro Cedar Grove Efland/Cheeks Heritage Center- Under Task Force Under ' Task Force Task Force Task Force No current Task Force • Task Force' Current Construction Report2004. Current Construction Report2004 Current" Report2004"' Current Report2004 Report2004 Report2004 2008' 2024 estimate 2009 2024 estimate 2024 estimate 2024 estimate Facility 2024 estimate • Design Population(anent/20z4estimate) , 75,000 75,000_ 100,000 53,416 53,416 . 93,000 21,000 40,000 7,150 10,000 Book Collection 20,000 .95,546 92,724 200,000 162,607 305,166 301,605 20,295 80,000 6,750 15,000 20,000 Periodicals(titles). 50 232 200 400 253 300 342 ' 61 150 14 35 50 Audio Recordings 2,500 1,990 3,000 20,000 13,043 59,590 54,900 1,191 5,000 164 1,000 1,250 Video Recordings 2,500 1,695 3,000 10,000 9 7,244 9,500 1,313, 3,000 245 500 750 Catalog Workstations 2 3 6 10 - 17 .20 32 1 4 1 • 2 2 •Other Public Wothat40ons 4 3 9 20 3 16 12 9 10 1 8 • 4 Computer Lab 0 11 16 25 24. 34 30 0 10 4 0 • 10 . Self-Check Stations 0 0 3 4 0 8 4 1 2 11 ' 0 1 • Copy Machines 1 1 1 5 2 3 5 2 1 1 1 1 .Reader Seats 50 50 90 250 • • 101 222 279 120 150 4 35 50 Meeting Room 1 Seating 100 20 100 200 85 84 150 0 100 . 0 60 75 Meeting Room 2 Seating a 0 0 65 25 144 85 0 0 . 0 0 0 Conference Room 1 Seating 0 0 6 25 ' 0 26 25 0 25 0 0 0 Conference Room 2 Seating 0 0 0 12 12 0 0 0 0 12 Study Room 1 Seating Bseats(1room) 0 6(1). 6(1) 2 6(2) 6(1) 0 6(1) 0'. 0 0 Study Room 2 Seating 0 0 2(2) 2(6) 2 2(4) 2(4) 0 2(1) 0 2(1).. 2(1) Children's Program Room• 0 0 ' 0 40 30 ,32 500 sq ft 0 . 30 seats 0 #Staff Workstations ' Circulation-Public 1 3 '2 4 4 3 5 2 3 1 1 2 Circulation-Office 0 1 3 6 7 9 10 1 4 1 1 3 Reference-Public 1 1 2 3 5 4 3 1 0 0 Reference-Office 1 2 3 8 . 4 7 7 1 0 • 0 ' Children's-Public 0 0 2 2 2 3 2 1 1 .1 Children's-Office 0 2 4 4 4 8 1 1 1 Administration 1 2 3 5 3 3 3 6 1 1 1 Technical Services 0 3 4 7 6 12 9 1 0 0 0 Outreach 0 1 0 2 D 0 0 0 0 0 •Construction 2008 does not reflectwhatwas proposed In 2004 Task Force Report,1/3 report design. . "Cybrary and Carrboro McDougle.figures are reflected in these totals. • "'The Task Force Report 012004 proposed one Southwest Regional Branch. • • Library Services Task Force 2007-ATTACHMENT 2 • Service Standards Compliance as of March 2008 • South East South West North Region . Region Central Region Region Region • Service Standards as presented to the BOCC and Heritage Nab- p Wand • accepted on presented to Center Cansime don Chapel Hlll Can-boro" Cedar Grave Cheeks Financial Impact/Comments 1 "Malarial cost Adult books- • $27.47;Children's Books-$21.10; I DVD-$20;Audiovisual-$55 as 1 per School Library Journal, • Access to library collections and services shall be free tn I Future "Keeping up with the joneses: aIlresideuts ofOtaogeCouuty.Fines and adrerebarges Planned Average Book prices 2008" 1 shall be establishedwithcondderadanlbrimpactoa I J J J J Facility Kenney,Brian 3/1/08 access. I 'One professional staff member annually=$52,000 including • I benefits as of 3/1/06-as per I Orange County grade 16 librarian 1 beginning salary I of Library facilities shall be located within a 15 minute drive This branch is for Library/square cost min 8 • . of all Orao Orange residents and be located as or near I citizens of Northern inequipme tcost or2 ,000,sq g County Future in equipmentcostfor29,000sq well traveledthomughfarrsaod,ifatall possible, * j Otange;ltis more than Pined footfacifdyinGary,NorthCaroBna 2 coaveeieutto public transportation.Adequate J J J 15 minutes from some p tc ent tag Facility as per Library Journal,12/15/07- sbell be available adjaceotm alllibrary facilities with space citizens of Northern "Library Buildings 2007:Going. for bsedieappedparimg i Orange. Goina.Green"Fox,Bette Lee Library facilities shall be designed and equippedtn This branch Future 3 accommodate theplamudprogram of services for the * J / This branch does not Lamlity and shall comply withapplicable provisions ofibe rl does not meet Planned See#2 this standard meet this standard Facility • Americans with Disabilities Act l• (�• Sufficient space shall be provided for collection display, I Future This branch Future `�v 4 public seating,planned equipment and technology,staff dE i J This hdaesnot wade and training areas,storage,ehibitareas,meeting and planned does not meet Planned See#2 expansion this standard meet this standard Facility program areas. • • • 4111) • . ' • • . . . . . . • • • . . • . • .. • . . . • . . . • • • . • . • . • .. . , . . . . • . . . • . . . . , . . • . • . Library Services Task Force 2007-ATTACHMENT 2 • Service Standards Compliance as of March 2008 . South East South West North Region West Region Central Region Region Region • Service Standards as presented to the BOCC and Heritage Main- p .. Effand accepted on rated to Center co nsztrarase•ran Chapel Hill Carrbru Cedar Grave Cheeks Financial Impact/Comments One.professional staff member Library services shalt be offered on aregular and I This shared . cansishatschedule includ ngmoming aftemaon,evening :e j facility limits Hours limited by Future annually=$52 000 including 5 aadweekendhours. enhenrsshallbe'caaveeientro J hours of staffing Planned benefits as oF 311/08-as per �P � Facility Orange County grade 16 librarian• library users. operation beginning salary I All services afthe Library faclity wllibe available when it This shared Future 6 is open.TheMamLibrmyaadt7rapetklilPublicLibrary * faciity limits' f Planned See#5 shallbeo eeaaminimnaaf60hoursperweekandb ranch I J hours of Facility • libraries sbaltbs open a minimum of40 hams per week.' I operation I I The collections robe MainLibrary and at the Chapel Frill Material cost Adult books- PublicLibrazy shall be comprehensive and developed to $27.47;Children's Books-$21.10; supportlbeneeds of the public:in addition to print • I Future DVD-$20;Audiovisual-$55 as 7 resources,high quality marerials shall be provided ina * I J J N/A N/A Planned per School LlbraryJournal, variety of audiovisual and electronic formals.Materials in Facility "Keeping upwifhtheJoneses: _ non-English languages appropriate to the commmmity shall Average Book prices 2008° he included_ I Kenney,Brian 3/1/08 Branch libraries shallbave basic reference collections and awr 'ten collection development plan appropriate for the I- Future O needs ofthecommunity.The collection plan shall be made * I N/A N/A f _ f Planned See#5 U publiclyavaiable,reviewedannual lyandberesponsiveto i IY R �t fl Facility citizens'suggestions for service improvements and enhancements. I i Future Workstation-$2000;Copier Well maintahredmd5mctiaeiogequipment shall be * / / $4000;Printer$2500;Wireless ' 9 ava0able for public and staff at all facilities Y Y Planned Modem-$100;Proxy Server-$9- p I Facility• 12,000. • • I. • • • . • • • • • ' • Library Services Task Force 2007-ATTACHMENT 2 • Service Statidards Compliance as of March 2008 ' South•East South West North Region West Region Central Region Region . Region .. • Service Standards as presented to the BOCC and Heritage warn" p Ef7and accepted on 1213108 Center constru8 don Cha el Hill Carrbord*` Cedar Grove Cheeks Financial impact/Comments Public access to the Interact shall be made available at all I facilities. Inhuming With Orange County's belief in Ml • Future • 10 andfreepublicus gnofilters wilbepeovidedon * J '. Planned See#9 computers available to adultusers.A writtenInteinetUse I Facility Policy wilt bepeovidedonthellbrary'swebsite. -- I • Orange Cmmtyresidents shall hav4 tee and convenient I Future 11 accesstomateriaisnotowaedby the localllbrary facuity * I / / • f J Planned See#9 thmagleiofralbtaryandmterlbratyloan.Networked �f Y • electronic information shall also be freely available. I Facility I The library and its supportive orgaairations(Friends, I - FoundaGon)sitalibe adiveparticipanteincommunity and * Future 12 inter-]dtraryplamimg effortsto enrich educational, ∎ J V J J Planned economic,cultural,and social opparmnities. I Facility • I . Meeting moms shall be made available accoidingto clearly I See#2 defined.and writle npoliciesat the MaiaLibraryand This branch' Future (Carrboro Cybrary,McDougle,and * I / This branch does not 13 Chapel BiillPublicLibray and atthose branches where f Y does not meet Planned CedarGrovebtanchesmayhave meeting rooms are available. 'Are writtenmeetingroom I standard. meetstandatd Facility _ proximate rooms available pelicyshall be provided ea the llbmry's website. I through other agencies) I Up-to-date teeimology.(e.g,computers,printers,copiers I This branch Future See#9;The Goal is available • andthe like)shall be available at all library facilities.Each * meets standard Thls branch does not • 14 lib�yfacility shalhaveatleastonecomputerworkstation I J due to shared meet standard. Planned current hange technology as . may .. . , Facility change as needed a for every 2,500 people in its designated service area facility. J I . Cybrary-yes; • • • I CatTforo Future auctions to.rmjltiess�•ca * I j j Mcgougle does J Planned See#g not meet due to Facility I shared facility III 0---- 0 . 0 OH • • Library Services Task Force 2007-ATTACHMENT 2 Service Standards Compliance as of March 2008 South East South West North Region West Region • Central•Region Region Region •Service Standards as presented to the BOCC and Heritage construct-ran Chapel Hill Carrboro** Cedar Grove Cheeks FrancialImpact/Comments accepted on 1213106 Center 2000 I . 'The Heritage i Centerisan . important part of! •Information 1 • Services to ; Reference assistance and community information shall be Orange • made available ataghbrary facilities during all opening County.The I - Future c • 16 horns. Genealogic information plus state,local and firmly Center was a i J I J J Planned See#5 . history shall also be made available ataspecializedfacility recammendat. Facility designated as the Orange County Heritage Center. ion In 2004 I .Reportanda final decision on; location and services has not/ been identified.1 • jFunds CHPL does Programs shall be plamredto meet theneedsandinterests Thfsbranch • Future One Large Program=$500- 1 * requested not provide This branch does not of children I does not meet Planned 1000;Small program for 35= shall ro0ectlibrary services and objectves ,to meetthis adult standard. meet standard. Facility $200 (standard. programs Programs specific to the needs of children andrheir I This branch Future 18 caregiversshall be provided atallfacrl'rdesonaregulady * J � . J does notmeet This branch does not Planned See#17 scheduledhasis standard. meetstandard. Facility I One professional staff member I annually=$52,000 including • Outreach services shall be provided for individuals and * Some ofisita This h2nch Future benefits as of 311/013-as per This branch does not I J programming does not meet Planned Orange County grade 16 librarian groups unable to use services offered in library hankies meet standard. Facility beginning salary for Is offered. standard dy 9 9 . • onetime purchase of van+$1500 - I in annual operating costs I • • • • • • • • • • Library Services Task Farce 2007-ATTACHMENT 2 • Service Standards Compliance as of March 2008 South East -South West' North Region West Region Central Region Region Region • Service Standards as presented to the BOCC and Heritage ,v accepted on 1213108 Center Constrnct-ton Chapel Hill Carrhoro" Cedar Grove Cheeks Financiallmpact/Comments wo8 Professionally trainedhbradans shall be available at all jA library facilities.AttheMain Library and ChapelBEI 'has been See#5 Pub BcIabrarypmfessianaU traioedhbtariaasshallbe has been Future Y * ( J Cybrery meets This branch does not (Professionally trained Iihrerians 20 ava0ableatauhoorsthehb uo en Atbranch made for Planned raY P Iadditianai • this standard, meet standard. Facility holds a Masters degree and is libraries,professionalytrained librariansshall beavailable staffing slate certification) far themajority of open hours. I i Srafftrainedmadvising adults aadyouihin their choice of I / Future 21 rcedmg mrespoadingmbasicinfo®ationandreference * I I J y Planned See#5 questiaas,andm use oflibrary resources shall be available d Facility at allfac0ities at all hours the libraries are open. I ty I The Main Library and Chapel Hill Public Library shall I have at leastthree distinct staffed service areas: 7 Future 22 circulation,reference and children'sservices. Planned See#5 Professionalyfrained librarians shall be available to I J J N/A N/A • provide children's and reference services at these locations I Facility all hours the library is open tI Awebsh'swithsearchable online catalog shallbemade See#5;This includes access to availablenwilkoearubs TLeanlinealogshltbemtlde * I ! Future NC LIVE,eboaks&databases. 23 holdingsoldrefacility.Thewebriteshauprovidelinksm J J �( J Planned Available resources for public may other arealibrarywebpages and collections I Facility be restricted,due to connection ' I availability. , Library book collections shall provide aminimum of 2.5 IBlanch will items per capita.The Main Library shall calculate , collections�on the basis oftheco o population. 'not meet See#7;Library is exploring other GYP P This branch This branch does not Future alternatives far meeting the • O *• 'standard 24 Chapel 73i01'ublieLrbraryshall calculate collection sizeaa I J does not meet Planned g •the basis ofthe municipal populationofChapelSrlL Each because of standard. meetstandatrl. FacTty standard,,ebook,etc. brandk wilcalcujate its collection size based on the per (space callections,ebaoks,etc. capilaelthe desigaatedpopuladonareaserverl 'limitations. •The Heritage Center is an important part of Information Services to Orange County. The Center was a recommendation in.2004 Report and a final decision on location and services has not been identified. Analysis includes Cybrary and Carrboro McDougle services. 4111 • 0- Ng /tit\ Attachment 5 ����lIJ��J 12/01/2008 III . Attachment 5. Cross-Reference FY 2008-18 and FY 2009-19 Unfunded County Needs FY 2009-19 CIP Fiscal Year Capital Projected Annual Operating Document Requested Request Impact Page# Cross- Reference Unfunded County Needs 1 County Facilities&Technology 2 Central Orange Senior Center Expansion General Purpose Space 2017-18 $2,880,000 Unspecified Appendix B (8,000 square feet) 3 Parks Operations Base Construction of 10,000square 2010-11 $5,071,500 $100,550 Appendix B foot facility and pole sheds Construction of 7,500 square 4 Recreation&Parks Administrative foot building to house 2011-12 $5,060,000 $50,000 Appendix B Headquarters administrative offices of Recreation and Parks 5 Seymour Center Expansion Wellness Center Expansion 2009-10 $397,500 Unspecified Appendix B (1,500 square feet) 6 Seymour Center Expansion Adult Day Health Center 2013-14 $2,170,000 Unspecified Appendix B (7,000 square feet) _ 7 Seymour Center Expansion General Purpose Space 2017-18 $4,680,000 Unspecified Appendix B (13,000 square feet) 8 Total Unfunded County Facilities&Technology Needs $20,259,000 9 10 Land Opportunities Ranges from$1,000 per year in 11 Agricultural Conservation Easements Acquisition of Easements On-going $2,925,000 early years of project to$6,000 per m year in later years a m a Ranges from$1,000 per year in D d m c 12 Cultural&Archaeological Sites Acquisition of land On-going $828,000 early years of project to$2,000 per u i o • year in later years m t g m Ranges from$1,000 per year in z L�'a 13 Future Parkland Purchases Acquisition of land On-going $1,526,000 early years of project to$2,000 per 3 m E year in later years c°.-o 14 Future Trails Acquisition of land On-going $2,152,000 Unspecified r.o Ranges from$3,000 per year in a,°'n w 15 Nature Preserves&Wildlife Habitats Acquisition of land On-going $3,465,000 early years of project to$6,000 per < E year in later years v 16 Watershed Buffer Lands Acquisition of land On-going $1,100,000 Unspecified m 17 Total Unfunded Land Opportunities Needs $11,996,000 18' 19 Park Development • 20 Fairview Park Future Park Development 2016-17 $1,210,000 $20,000 30 21 Gymnasium Construction of gymnasium Unspecified Unspecified Unspecified 52 Ranges from$20,000 per year in Haw River Access&Mountains to Sea 2011-12 and 22 Trail Future Development 2016-17 $1,185,000 early years of project to$50,000 per 54 year in later years 23 Hollow Rock Preserve Future Park Development 2015-16 $622,000 $125,800 56 24 Millhouse Road Park&Soccer Center Future Park Development 2014-15 $7,190,000 $377,000 52 25 New Hope Park(a),Blackwood Farm Future Park Development 2016-17 $4,375,000 $364,170 10 26 Northeast Park Future Park Development 2016-17 $7,400,000 $327,380 58 27 Northern Park Future Park Development 2012-13 $1,600,000 Unspecified 62 28 River Park Future Park Development 2014-15 $125,000 $18,000 Not included 29 Seven Mile/McGowan Creek Preserve Future Park Development 2015-16 $1,416,000 $150,550 82 30 Smith Municipal Fields 31 Twin Creeks Park Future Park Development 2015-16 $9,670,000 $408,000 80 32 Upper New Hope Creek Rustic Woodland Creation of trail 2015-16 $322,000 Unspecified Trail 33 West Ten Park Future Park Development 2010-11 $600,000 Unspecified 84 34 White Cross Park Future Park Development 2015-16 $6,390,000 $327,500 8 35 Total Unfunded Park Development Needs $42,105,000 36 Total Unfunded County Needs $74,360,000 • 410 • 0<1 Attachment 6 • Impact Statement of Postponing Central Permitting Technology Initiative • The Planning and Information Technologies Departments have collaborated on the following statement regarding the postponement of the Central Permitting • Technology Initiative: While the increased reliance on Permits Plus is an interim solution, we feel in the interest of meeting urgent needs with limited resources, it is the most expedient path to pursue in achieving the desired synergies. We anticipate the long term • solution will rely on a technology that meets long term strategic goals. We will work to implement this tactical solution with a eye toward that strategic goal. • •